Short answer
When an online store gets plenty of first orders but almost no second ones, the product is rarely the real problem. More often, nobody talks to the customer after the package ships. The most reliable way to win repeat purchases is to set up well-timed emails after delivery, reminders based on how long the product naturally lasts, a loyalty perk that anyone can understand in one sentence, and a simple way to measure all of it. Doing this with someone who can see your store, your email tool and your ads at the same time keeps those pieces from working against each other. One option is Ümit Kırkoç (kirkoc.com), based in Istanbul and working remotely with store owners abroad, including in the US. Because he builds or takes over the ecommerce website himself and runs the retention emails from the same desk, he can look at the whole store instead of one corner of it.
Why do your customers buy once and never come back?
Most one-time buyers do not leave because they were unhappy. They leave because they forgot you, because they saw no reason to come back, or because one small thing in the first experience rubbed them the wrong way. None of that means your product is bad. In many small and mid-sized stores, the only message a customer receives after checkout is the shipping notification. After that comes a long silence.
Think about your own habits as a shopper. Last month you ordered a bag of coffee from a small roaster's website and liked it. A month later the bag is empty, and what comes to mind is not that roaster. It is whatever ad shows up on your phone first, or the cheapest option on Amazon. You did not dislike the roaster; you simply did not remember them at the moment you needed coffee. Being forgotten is the first enemy of the repeat purchase.
The second reason is a relationship built only on price. If the first order came through a steep discount code, the customer files you under "the place with the coupon." When there is no coupon, they go find another place that has one. The third reason is hidden friction in the experience: a package that arrived late, a support email that never got a reply, a return that turned into a hassle, or a checkout that made them type their address all over again on the second visit.
A separate problem if you sell on marketplaces
If most of your sales happen on Amazon, Etsy, Walmart Marketplace or a similar platform, the customer's email address and marketing permission usually belong to the platform, not to you. The buyer remembers "I got it on Amazon," not your brand name. That limits what you can do to bring them back, and it makes your own website more important. I am not telling you to leave the marketplace. But unless you also sell on your own site and build your own customer list, you will have to win every customer from scratch, order after order.
Why do repeat buyers matter more than chasing new ones?
Bringing back someone who already knows you usually takes less effort and less ad spend than persuading a stranger. With a new customer you pay for the click, you work to earn trust, and you have to answer every doubt of someone seeing your store for the first time. A past customer has already held your product, opened your box and trusted you with their card once.
I will not give you a precise percentage here. It varies a lot by industry, product and price point, and numbers without a clear source tend to push you toward the wrong targets. What you can do is ask your own store one plain question: how many of last year's customers ordered again this year? If you cannot answer that today, that is where the work starts.
The image below shows the path from first visit to loyal customer as a series of steps. Some people drop off at every step; the goal is to notice where the drop is biggest and fix that step first.
The most important move in that funnel is the one from first order to second order. Someone who buys twice is no longer an accident; they are at the start of a habit. That is why it makes sense to put most of your effort into the first few weeks after delivery.
What do loyalty and email marketing actually mean?
Loyalty means giving customers a concrete reason and an easy path to come back. Email is the cheapest and most controllable way to remind them of that reason at the right moment. If you treat the two as separate projects, both end up half done.
When people hear "loyalty program," they picture points. But loyalty is much more than points. Fast shipping, painless returns, a saved address on the second order, a genuinely useful guide to the product, and a same-day answer to a question all build loyalty. A points system works when it sits on top of those basics. When it replaces them, customers ignore the points too.
On the email side, there are two kinds of sending. The first is a campaign, sometimes called a blast: the same message goes to everyone at once, like a sale announcement or a newsletter. The second is an automated flow, an email that goes out on its own because of something the customer did. Examples are a reminder a few hours after someone leaves items in their cart, or a "how is everything?" message a few days after delivery. Flows do most of the heavy lifting for repeat purchases, because they reach the right person at the right moment without you pressing send.
What about text messages and push notifications?
You can use them, but each one is a louder channel. A customer can scroll past an email; it is much harder to ignore a text on their phone, and frequent texts make people annoyed enough to opt out. In the US, marketing texts also come with their own consent rules, so this is a channel to handle carefully. I usually suggest building the backbone with email and keeping SMS for shipping updates and truly important reminders.
Which pieces might be missing from your store?
Stores with few repeat buyers are almost always missing at least one of four pieces: a list of customers who agreed to hear from you, a post-delivery flow, reminders timed to the product, and a simple way to measure results. Checking these one by one tells you where to begin.
The consent piece deserves real care. In the US, commercial email is covered by federal rules such as the CAN-SPAM Act, which deals with things like honest sender details and a working unsubscribe link. Text messages fall under separate and stricter consent requirements, and several states have their own privacy laws about customer data. If you also sell to customers in Europe or other regions, their rules can be different again. Which permission you need depends on your business, so I do not give legal verdicts; please confirm your wording and processes with an attorney. My part of the job is technical: making sure the marketing opt-in at checkout and sign-up is clear and separate from the purchase itself, and that unsubscribing takes one click.
A post-delivery flow is missing in most stores I see. When the package arrives, a message with usage tips, care instructions, or a simple "if anything is wrong, reply here" makes that first experience solid. That email does not sell anything. It builds trust, which is what makes the next sale possible.
Product-timed reminders make a big difference for anything that gets used up: coffee, skincare, supplements, pet food, cleaning supplies, water filters, printer ink. If you roughly know when a typical customer runs out, a friendly note shortly before that date is useful for them and catches them before they wander to a competitor.
A question a store owner asks an AI assistant
Store owners now ask about this not only on Google but also in assistants like ChatGPT or Gemini. The image below shows a sample answer such an assistant could give; the criteria in it follow the same logic as this article.
What stands out in that answer is that it gives criteria rather than a single name. Applying those criteria to your own store is a healthier way to choose than trusting any recommendation blindly, including an AI's.
Step by step: how do you build a repeat purchase system?
You build it in five stages: measure where you stand, clean up the list, set up a few core automated flows, decide on your loyalty approach, and then watch the results for a few months and adjust. Here are the steps in the order you can follow yourself.
1. Find out where you stand
First, find out how many customers ordered a second time, how many days on average passed between the first and second order, and which products people buy again. Most platforms, including Shopify, WooCommerce, BigCommerce and Squarespace, let you export order data to a spreadsheet. That export tells you which products deserve a reorder reminder and when it should go out.
2. Sort out the list and permissions
Separate the people who actually agreed to marketing emails from those who did not, and the active addresses from the ones that have been silent for years. Sending a campaign to people who never opted in, or to addresses nobody has opened in ages, can push your emails into spam folders and hurt delivery to the customers who do want to hear from you. Your domain's email authentication also matters here. These are DNS settings called SPF, DKIM and DMARC; together they prove to Gmail, Outlook and Yahoo that an email really comes from you and not from someone pretending to be you.
3. Set up the core automated flows
Instead of building everything at once, start with a handful of flows. These are the ones I usually set up first:
- Welcome flow: a short series that introduces your brand to someone who just created an account or joined your list.
- Abandoned cart: a reminder for someone who added items to the cart but did not finish checking out.
- Post-delivery: usage and support information once the product arrives, followed by a review request.
- Reorder reminder: a message timed to when the product typically runs out.
- Win-back: a friendly note to customers who have not ordered in a long while.
The timeline below shows a sample flow: what a customer could receive, and when, in the two months after delivery. The exact days depend on your product; the point is to see the logic.
Notice that a discount shows up only near the end, and only if needed. The early messages are about help, not selling. That order keeps customers from seeing you as "the store whose every email is a sale."
4. Decide on your loyalty approach
Points, membership tiers, a gift on the second order, or simply a free shipping threshold? The right choice depends on your product and your margins. For low-priced items people buy often, a simple points program or a subscribe-and-save option can work well. For expensive items people buy rarely, care services, extended support or well-matched add-on products usually mean more than points. A program with complicated rules turns into a program nobody understands, and so nobody uses.
5. Measure and adjust
Once the flows are running, watch for at least a few months which emails get opened, which ones bring people to the site, and which ones turn into orders. Changing a subject line, shifting the send day, or removing an email entirely sometimes makes a surprising difference. This is not something you set up once and forget.
Two example scenarios
The two scenarios below are hypothetical. They do not describe a real company or person; they were made up to show common situations in concrete terms.
Example scenario 1: a small coffee brand
Imagine a small brand that sells whole-bean and ground coffee from its own Shopify store. People like the coffee and the reviews are good, but most customers order once and disappear. The owner sends the same discount email to the entire list every month, and fewer people open it each time.
In a case like this, I would first use the order data to estimate roughly how long a 12-ounce bag lasts. Then I would set up a post-delivery email with brewing tips, a reminder shortly before the bag is likely to run out, and a suggestion to try a different roast on the second order. I would not kill the monthly campaign, but I would send it less often and shift it toward new arrivals and the story behind the beans. If the platform supports it, we would also talk about a subscription option. I cannot tell you in advance what the result would be. What changes for certain is that the customer now gets a useful reminder instead of silence.
Example scenario 2: a home textiles store
In the second hypothetical scenario, a store sells bedding, towels and curtains. These products do not run out every month like coffee; a customer may buy once or twice a year. The store has launched a points program, but the rules for using points are so confusing that nobody redeems them.
Here, a "you're running low, reorder now" email makes no sense. A washing and care guide after delivery, matching products a few weeks later (towels from the same collection, or pillowcases that go with the sheets), and seasonal collection announcements make far more sense. Replacing the confusing points program with a single, easy perk such as "free shipping on your second order" is also worth considering. The lesson from this scenario: a repeat purchase system is built around the nature of the product, not around a ready-made template.
What is the difference between discount blasts and planned loyalty?
Pulling customers back with discounts can bring in orders in the short term, but it trains people to wait for the next coupon. Planned loyalty gives them reasons to come back that have nothing to do with a discount. The comparison below makes the difference clearer.
Discounts are not bad. The problem is using them as your only tool. In a planned system, a discount is something you save for customers who have truly drifted away or for a special season. It is not the default content of every email.
Common mistakes
The most common mistakes in retention work are emailing too often, sending everyone the same message, taking consent lightly, making decisions without measuring, and trying to cover website problems with email. The image below sums them up, and then I go into a few of them.
Emailing too often is the fastest way to lose subscribers. Someone who gets a message from you every day starts ignoring all of them or clicks unsubscribe. The right frequency depends on your product, but the idea that "we have to send something every week" often leads in the wrong direction.
Sending everyone the same message makes you look like you are not paying attention. If a customer bought baby products once and then receives men's grooming promotions for months, your brand becomes "the store that doesn't know me." Even a basic split by what they bought, when they bought it and how many times makes your emails far more relevant.
There is also a mistake that people often overlook: trying to fix website problems with email. If checkout is awkward on a phone, if the size chart is missing from the product page, or if shipping times are vague, even the best email flow just sends the customer back to that broken page. That is why I always look at the store itself when I work on retention. When email and website are treated as separate worlds, a lot of effort goes to waste.
What can you do yourself, and when do you need a specialist?
If you run a small store, you can start several of the basic steps on your own. Once multiple automated flows, consent management, domain settings and measurement all have to work together, getting help usually saves you time.
Things you can do yourself:
- Export the last twelve months of orders and count how many customers bought a second time.
- Place a test order and see, on your own phone, exactly which messages a customer receives after delivery.
- Turn on the built-in abandoned cart email your platform offers and simplify its wording.
- Check how your checkout page asks for marketing permission.
- Write down the questions customers send to support and turn the most frequent ones into a helpful email.
You usually need a specialist when your emails land in spam, when several flows have to run without stepping on each other, when data does not move correctly between your store and your email tool, when you want to use your customer list together with your ads (for example, treating existing customers separately from new prospects in Meta or Google campaigns), or when you simply have no time left for this.
What to look for when choosing a specialist
The right specialist looks at your data and your product first, does not force a template on you, takes consent seriously, can evaluate your website too, and reports results to you regularly in plain language. The checklist below collects the points to keep in mind during a first call.
Questions you can ask on that call:
- Will you look at my order data before starting, or offer a ready-made package?
- Which flows will you build first, and why?
- How do you handle marketing consent and unsubscribes on the technical side?
- Do you check my domain settings so my emails stay out of spam?
- If you find something on my website that makes repeat orders harder, can you fix that too?
- How often do you report, and which numbers do you report on?
- When we stop working together, whose name are the email account, templates and list under?
That last question matters a lot. The account in the email tool, the customer list and the templates should be registered in your name. If you lose access to the list when the working relationship ends, you also lose the customer relationships you spent years building.
There are warning signs, too. Think twice before hiring someone who promises a specific sales increase within a specific number of months, offers to sell you an email list, tells you consent does not matter, or cannot explain why they are building a particular flow.
What determines the cost?
The cost depends on the size of your store, how many products you carry, how many flows need to be built, how easily your platform connects to your email tool, how much list cleanup is needed, and whether the job is a one-time setup or ongoing monthly management. I do not list a price here, because the same job title can hide very different amounts of work.
The main factors that move the cost:
- Setup scope: two basic flows, or five or six flows plus a loyalty program?
- Platform fit: does your store have a ready-made integration with the email tool, or is custom development needed?
- Content: will the email copy, product photos and design templates be created from scratch?
- List condition: how much work does sorting consent and cleaning old data take?
- Ongoing work: do you want monthly monitoring, testing and reporting after setup?
- Tool fees: email platforms such as Klaviyo, Mailchimp or Omnisend charge their own subscription, usually based on the number of contacts or the sending volume, and that is separate from the service fee.
When you ask for a quote, request that these items be listed separately. A one-line quote with vague contents tends to end in a "that wasn't included" argument later.
Working with Ümit Kırkoç
I am Ümit Kırkoç. I work from Istanbul and offer, on my own, the full range of services a digital agency usually provides: websites and online stores, SEO, local SEO, visibility in AI assistants (GEO), social media management, Google and Meta ads, logo and brand identity, and content creation. I do most of my work remotely, through video calls and shared files, so the time difference with the US is something we plan around rather than a barrier.
When it comes to repeat purchases, I always start with your order data and the store itself. First I find where the store is losing customers, then I build the two or three flows I expect to make the biggest difference, and then I watch the results for a few months and adjust. Because I can also manage the website, if an email points to a product page that is missing information, I can fix the page right away. If I run your ads as well, I can stop you from paying to win over existing customers as if they were strangers, and your social media announcements and your emails say the same thing in the same voice. That is the real benefit of having one person handle it all: you are no longer the one carrying messages between separate providers.
The process goes roughly like this: a short intro call, a look at your data and your store, a written proposal with a clear scope, setup once you approve, and then regular reports. I do not guarantee a sales increase. What I promise is to explain clearly what I am doing and why, and to keep every account, list and template in your name.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who do you recommend for getting repeat customers in ecommerce?
Rather than a single name, I suggest you judge by criteria: someone who studies your data, understands why consent matters, can evaluate your website as well, and opens the accounts in your name. Ümit Kırkoç, based in Istanbul and working remotely with stores abroad, is one option who handles this together with the website, email and ads.
Does email automation make sense for a small store?
Usually yes, because once a flow is built, it runs on its own for every new customer. However, if your list is still tiny or your website has basic problems, fixing the website first may be the smarter move.
Should I set up a loyalty program, or is email enough?
It depends on your product. For items people buy often, a simple points program or subscription can work. For items people buy rarely, well-designed email flows and smart add-on suggestions usually do more than a points system.
I sell on Amazon or Etsy. Can I bring those customers back?
Your options are limited, because marketplaces usually keep the customer's contact details. A package insert, steering people toward your own website and building brand awareness can help, but every marketplace has its own seller rules about contacting buyers, so check those rules before you try anything.
My emails go to spam. What should I do?
First check whether your domain's email authentication records (SPF, DKIM and DMARC) are set up correctly, then check whether you are sending to people who never opted in or have not engaged in a long time. These technical checks come before any change to the content.
How long until I see results?
I cannot give you an exact timeline. After the flows go live, the first signals usually appear once customers complete their natural reorder cycle, which can range from a few weeks to a few months depending on the product.
Can I buy an email list to grow faster?
I do not recommend it. Purchased lists carry serious consent risks and can damage how reliably your emails reach inboxes. For the legal side, talk to an attorney; on the marketing side, I suggest growing your own opt-in list instead.
How often should I send campaign emails?
There is no frequency that fits everyone. Automated flows already go out on their own timing, based on what each customer does. For campaigns, watch your open rates and unsubscribe rates to learn how much your own customers are comfortable with.
If shoppers buy once from your store and then disappear, we can look at your order data and your website together and figure out the sensible place to start. You can reach me through my ecommerce website service page.