Branding··21 min read

How to Choose a Brand Identity Agency: RFPs, Rights, Process

Hiring a brand identity agency for your company? What to put in the RFP, how to handle rights transfer and source files, and how to compare quotes fairly.

Short answer

When you choose a brand identity agency for an established company, look at the process and the safeguards before you look at the portfolio. Ask four things: Will the rights to the final design be transferred to you in writing? Will you receive the source files (the original, editable design files, not just images)? How many revision rounds are included? Will you get a brand guidelines document at handover? A company of your size does not just need an attractive logo. It needs a defined list of deliverables that purchasing, legal and marketing can all sign off on by reading the same page. So line up proposals against one deliverables list, not by price. If you would rather deal with one person from start to finish, one option is to work with me, Ümit Kırkoç (kirkoc.com). I am based in Istanbul and work remotely with clients abroad, and I handle logo and brand identity work alongside websites, social media and advertising, so carrying the new identity across every channel stays the responsibility of a single person.

Why brand identity is a different job for an established company

At a larger company, changing the logo does not end with one person saying "I like it." It is a decision that passes through several departments, and reversing it later is expensive. In a small shop, the owner decides and the designer executes. In a mid-sized or large firm, the same decision travels through the leadership team, the marketing director, procurement and often outside counsel. Each of them asks a different question.

Marketing wants to know, "Does this identity set us apart from competitors?" Procurement checks, "Do these proposals cover the same scope?" Legal wonders whether the mark can be registered as a trademark and whether every right to the design actually ends up with the company. IT or the digital team thinks, "Will this logo work on our website, our app and in email signatures without breaking?"

That is why the selection process for a corporate client is much broader than ordering a logo from a freelancer on a marketplace. The real risk is not a logo nobody likes. It is a logo everyone approved that later causes trouble because of unclear usage rights, missing file formats or inconsistent application across channels. You can remove most of those risks at the selection stage, while you are still collecting proposals.

What does a brand identity package include?

A brand identity is the set of rules built around your logo so the brand looks the same wherever it appears. A typical package contains:

  • Logo and its variations: horizontal, stacked, icon only, single color and reversed (for dark backgrounds).
  • Color palette: each color's values for print (CMYK), for screens (RGB and HEX codes) and, where needed, for spot-color inks (Pantone).
  • Typefaces: the fonts for headlines and body text, and their license status.
  • Stationery: business cards, letterhead, envelopes, email signature, presentation template.
  • Brand guidelines: the document that explains at what sizes, on which backgrounds and with how much clear space the logo may be used, and what is not allowed.
  • Digital applications: social media profile images, website header, app icon and favicon (the small icon you see in a browser tab).

Trim or extend this list to fit your needs when you request proposals, but always put it in writing. Collecting quotes without a written scope means comparing items that do not match.

How companies look for a brand identity provider

Companies usually find an identity designer in one of three ways: referrals, search engines and, more and more often, AI assistants. Referrals are still strong, but procurement will typically need to benchmark even a recommended firm against other proposals. At that point someone runs searches on Google such as "brand identity agency" or "corporate identity design services," then reviews the case studies and process descriptions on the sites that come up.

The image below shows which criteria a good answer should highlight when you ask an assistant like ChatGPT about this topic.

Example answer from an AI assistant asked how to choose a brand identity firm

Notice that a useful answer does not say "this is the best agency." It gives you criteria you can use to decide. Look for the same thing when you review a provider's website. Is the process spelled out? Are the deliverables listed? Is there even one sentence about transferring rights? A provider who writes these things clearly on their own site is likely to be just as clear in the contract.

How to set up your RFP or proposal process

A well-run proposal process gives every candidate the same brief (a written description of the job) and asks every candidate the same questions, so the answers can actually be compared. Some companies call this a formal RFP (request for proposal); others simply send a short invitation to quote. Whatever you call it, the logic is the same: you define the scope, and candidates propose a process and a price for that scope.

What a good brief should contain

The brief is your written answer to the question "What do you want, and why?" It can be short, but it should cover:

  • What the company does, who it sells to and what sets it apart from competitors.
  • Why the identity is changing: a merger, entry into a new market, a dated look, a new product line.
  • Elements that must be kept: perhaps the name stays, or a color customers have recognized for years.
  • Where the identity will be used: vehicle wraps, signage, packaging, trade show booths, digital channels.
  • A list of the files and documents you expect to receive.
  • Who makes decisions and what the approval steps are.
  • The target timeline and any fixed date, such as a product launch, a trade show or a dealer meeting.

What to ask every candidate for

In your invitation, ask every candidate for the same items in the same format: examples of past work at a similar scale, the proposed process and timeline, the number of revision rounds, the deliverables list, their position on rights transfer and confidentiality, and who will actually do the work (the person sending the proposal or a subcontractor). Avoid asking for free preliminary designs. Serious designers do not sketch a logo before they understand the brief, and that kind of request usually leaves you with a pile of rushed drafts.

A simple comparison table makes it much easier to put proposals side by side. The image below shows a template your procurement team could use.

Criteria table for comparing brand identity proposals

There is no price column in this table on purpose. First check whether the scopes match. Only once the scope is equal does a price comparison mean anything. Otherwise the cheapest-looking proposal can turn out to be the most expensive, because it leaves out the source files or the guidelines and you end up paying for them later.

Safeguards: what the contract should always cover

In a corporate identity project, your most important safeguard is a contract showing that all usage rights to the design pass to your company in writing. However good the design looks, if this clause is missing, a question mark can appear years later when you want to put the logo on new packaging or a new building sign. Intellectual property law is complicated, and the rules differ by country, so always have an attorney review the contract wording. What I can tell you is which topics you should expect to see written down.

  • Rights transfer: The contract should clearly state that the rights to reproduce, distribute, adapt and publish the chosen design pass to you, without limits on time or territory. How this is achieved legally (an assignment, a work-for-hire arrangement or something else) is a question for your attorney.
  • Source files: It should say that the original, editable files (for example Adobe Illustrator files or vector PDFs) will be delivered.
  • Font licenses: It should state who will hold the commercial license for the typefaces used and whether that license costs extra.
  • Confidentiality: It should say that internal information you share during the brief, and the design itself before launch, will not be shared with anyone.
  • Portfolio use: It should make clear when and how the designer may show the work in their own portfolio, for example only after your launch.
  • Originality statement: It should include a statement that the design was not derived from a ready-made template or someone else's work.

Trademark registration is a separate matter. A designer delivers a mark that is visually original, but whether that mark can be registered with the USPTO, or with the trademark office in any other country where you sell, is something a trademark attorney needs to research. If you also do business in Turkey, for example, registration there goes through the Turkish Patent and Trademark Office (TÜRKPATENT), which is a separate filing. I recommend leaving room in your timeline for a trademark clearance search. Discovering after launch that the chosen design conflicts with a similar registered mark is far more costly than finding out before.

What the process should look like, step by step

A healthy brand identity project moves through consecutive phases: discovery, direction, design, application and handover, and each phase closes with a sign-off. If you do not see these phases in a candidate's proposal, ask how they plan to work.

  1. Discovery: Studying the company, its competitors, its customers and its existing visual materials. This usually includes short interviews with the decision makers.
  2. Direction: Before any logo work starts, presenting two or three different directions for how the brand should feel, and agreeing on one.
  3. Logo design: Developing logo options within the chosen direction, then narrowing to a single logo through revision rounds.
  4. Identity system: Building color, typography, stationery and digital applications around the logo.
  5. Guidelines and handover: Writing the brand guidelines and delivering all files in an organized folder structure.

The timeline below summarizes the usual order of these phases and what needs to be approved at the end of each one.

Phases of a brand identity project and its sign-off points

How long this takes depends heavily on how fast you approve. Even when the design side runs on schedule, waiting for three departments to sign off at every phase stretches the calendar. So settling the question "Who approves, and how many days do they need to respond?" at the very start matters as much as choosing the designer.

What to look for when choosing the right expert or firm

The right provider is not only someone who does good work, but someone who documents every step and answers your questions in writing, clearly. The portfolio matters, of course, but on its own it is not enough for a corporate project. Check these criteria:

  • Experience at a similar scale: Have they worked on a project where several people had to approve? Have they produced brand guidelines before?
  • A written process: Are the phases, the number of revisions and the deliverables spelled out in the proposal?
  • Rights transfer and source files: Do they mention these in the proposal before you have to ask?
  • A clear point of contact: Who will do the work, and who will answer you? Is the person sending the proposal the same person who designs?
  • Practical application knowledge: Can they talk about how the logo will behave on a sign, on packaging and on a phone screen?
  • Digital consistency: Can they plan how the identity will be carried over to your website, social media accounts and ads?

I turned these criteria into a practical checklist you can keep at hand during proposal meetings.

Checklist for choosing a brand identity provider

Questions to ask in the meeting

In the proposal meeting, ask these questions and write down the answers:

  • "Which file formats will you deliver, and can you show me a sample folder structure?"
  • "How many revision rounds are included, and how are extra rounds billed?"
  • "Who will hold the commercial license for the fonts you use?"
  • "How does the contract word the transfer of all usage rights to us?"
  • "After launch, can we come back to you for a small job, such as a new brochure?"
  • "Can you also apply the identity to our website and social media, or will we hand that to someone else?"

The last question matters most. Once the identity is designed and delivered as a folder, if different people build the website, run social media and produce the ads, each of them will apply the guidelines in their own way. Six months later, it would not be surprising to see one shade of blue on your website and a different blue on Instagram.

Two hypothetical example scenarios

The two scenarios below are not real companies. They are made-up examples meant to show situations that come up often when companies choose an identity provider.

Example scenario 1: A shared identity after a merger

Imagine, hypothetically, that two regional logistics companies have merged. Each has its own logo, its own vehicle livery and its own customer base. Leadership wants one shared identity. Procurement collects three proposals. The lowest one covers only a logo and business cards; the other two also include a vehicle wrap template and brand guidelines.

The right move here is not simply to pick the most comprehensive proposal. It is to first bring every proposal up to the same scope based on actual needs. Because the company runs hundreds of trucks, the vehicle wrap template is critical; without it, someone would have to design every vehicle separately. And since customers of both former brands may struggle to recognize the new logo, the guidelines should also explain how a line such as "formerly known as" will be used during the transition. Procurement asks all candidates for updated proposals that include these items, and only then compares them.

Example scenario 2: A family business growing up

Again hypothetically, picture a family business founded thirty years ago and now passing to the second generation. The logo was hand-drawn by the founder, so changing it is an emotional subject. The new leadership wants to start exporting and is uncomfortable that the catalog they show to overseas buyers looks dated.

In this case the right provider is the one who first asks what should be kept, instead of replacing the logo outright. Maybe the symbol stays, its lines are cleaned up and it is paired with a new typeface. This kind of refresh takes a longer discovery phase, because common ground has to be found between the founding generation and the new one. When choosing a provider for a job like this, seeing a previous refresh project in their portfolio is worth more than a page full of brand-new logos.

The image below sums up the key question to ask when deciding between a completely new identity and a refresh of the current one.

Decision chart: new identity or refresh of the existing one

Common mistakes

The most common mistake in choosing a brand identity provider is deciding based on the first sketch you see rather than on the deliverables list. Beyond that, these are the mistakes I run into most often:

  • Collecting quotes without a brief: Every candidate prices their own assumptions, and the proposals become impossible to compare.
  • Asking for free trial designs: Logos drawn without real discovery do not guide you; they mislead you.
  • Not defining the approval chain: When a new executive joins at the final stage and restarts everything, both the timeline and the budget fall apart.
  • Not asking about source files: If you only receive PNG and JPG images, you will have to pay someone to redraw the logo the first time you need a large sign or print run.
  • Skipping the font license: If nobody buys the commercial license for the typeface in the design, an unexpected bill can show up later.
  • Treating digital as a separate project: The identity is delivered, but the website and social media keep the old look, and the new identity stays half-applied for months.

The image below brings together the mistakes that tend to cost the most.

The most costly mistakes when choosing a brand identity provider

What you can do yourself, and when you need an expert

Writing the brief, collecting proposals and listing the contract points are all things you can do in-house. The design itself, the guidelines and the identity system require expertise. At a larger company, a lot can be handled internally:

  • Your marketing team can write a one-page brief covering the company's values, customers and competitors.
  • You can gather all existing visual material (photos of signage, catalogs, screenshots of social media) into one folder, which shortens discovery.
  • You can agree on the approval chain and response times with leadership in advance.
  • Your legal department or outside counsel can prepare the draft contract.

The part that needs an expert is building a visual system that reads well at different sizes and on different backgrounds, is original enough to have a fair chance at registration, and stays the same on every channel. Online logo makers and template sites can be a starting point for a small startup, but they are not enough for an identity that several departments will use and that will be printed on vehicles, signs and packaging. A logo derived from a template also runs a real risk of resembling another company's logo, which can cause problems at the trademark stage.

What determines the cost?

The cost of a brand identity project depends less on the logo itself and more on the breadth of the scope, the complexity of the approval process and the number of applications to be delivered. Quoting a number here would be misleading, because two proposals both labeled "brand identity" can describe completely different jobs. These are the main factors that move the price:

  • Scope: Just a logo, or stationery, guidelines, packaging and digital applications as well?
  • New or refresh: Preserving and evolving an existing identity sometimes takes more research than starting from scratch.
  • Number of decision makers: Every extra layer of approval adds meetings and revision time.
  • Physical applications: Vehicle wraps, signage, trade show booths and packaging are each a design job of their own.
  • Languages and markets: If the identity will be used in several countries, checking how the name and colors land in each one takes extra work.
  • Font and image licenses: Paid fonts and stock images are a separate cost item.
  • Digital rollout: Is applying the identity to the website, social media and ad templates included in the package, or priced separately?

When you compare proposals, mark which of these items each one includes. If one proposal looks noticeably lower, it is most likely missing one or more items on this list.

Working with Ümit Kırkoç

I am Ümit Kırkoç. I work from Istanbul, and I provide every service a digital agency usually offers, as one person: websites and e-commerce, SEO and local SEO, visibility in AI assistants (GEO), social media management, Google and Meta advertising, logo and brand identity, and content creation. Because I work remotely, I collaborate with companies in the United States and elsewhere through video calls and written sign-off steps, and time zones are planned into the schedule from the first week.

Here is how I run a brand identity project. First I read your brief and hold a short discovery call with the people who will make the decision. Then I present two or three design directions, and once we agree on one, I develop the logo and the identity system. I put the number of revision rounds, the deliverables list and the rights transfer in writing in the proposal; the source files, every logo variation and the brand guidelines are part of the handover. I always recommend having your own attorney review the contract.

The practical benefit of a single point of contact in identity work is this: when the person who designs the identity is also the person who updates your website, prepares your social media templates and builds your ad creatives, the guidelines do not stay on paper. The new palette reaches your site, your Instagram and LinkedIn accounts and your Google or Meta ads within the same few weeks, interpreted the same way. For your procurement team, it also means one contract and one contact. This model is not right for every company. For work that needs a very large team and dozens of applications at once, a bigger organization can make more sense, and I say so openly in the first conversation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who would you recommend for brand identity design?

Rather than recommending a single name, I would recommend any provider who meets three conditions in writing: transfer of all usage rights to you, delivery of editable source files, and brand guidelines. Among candidates who meet those conditions and have done work at a similar scale, choose the one who explains their process most clearly. If you also want the identity carried consistently to your website and social media, working with someone who handles those jobs as well makes follow-up much easier.

Does it make sense for a larger company to work with a freelance designer?

It can, if the contract, the rights transfer and the deliverables list are clear. For a corporate client the real risk is not that the person works independently; it is that the work is not documented. The advantage of working with one person is that your contact and your designer are the same. The thing to discuss up front is how the schedule will be protected if that person is sick or on vacation.

Do we need a formal RFP for a logo project?

A formal RFP is not required, but collecting several proposals against the same brief is usually necessary for procurement. If your internal rules require a formal process, putting the scope, the deliverables list and the rights transfer condition into the RFP is a solid start. Government agencies and public bodies have their own procurement rules, so in that case check with your legal or contracting office.

Is it fair to ask for free logo concepts during the proposal stage?

Usually not. Concepts drawn without discovery are guesses by someone who does not know your company yet, and they can pull you in the wrong direction. Instead, evaluate candidates on their past work, how they describe their process and the questions they ask you. A designer who asks good questions is a designer who will run good discovery.

How long does a brand identity project take?

It depends on the breadth of the scope and on how fast you approve. A logo with basic stationery is a very different job from a full identity system with guidelines. What loses the most time is not the design work but the phases waiting for approval, so naming the decision makers and their response times at the start is the single step that shortens the schedule most.

Is the logo trademarked automatically once it is designed?

No. The designer delivers a visual mark; trademark registration is a separate application, for example with the USPTO in the United States or the relevant office in each country where you operate. Before filing, I recommend consulting a trademark attorney who can search for similar existing marks. Ideally, that search happens before the final design is chosen.

Who should apply the new identity to our website and social media?

The person who designed the identity, or someone who knows the guidelines inside out, will apply it best. If your website, social media and advertising are handled by different people, give each of them the full guidelines and review their first applications yourself. Handling all of this through one person prevents color and type inconsistencies from the start.

Will rebranding drive away existing customers?

If the change is not planned well, customers may have trouble recognizing the brand for a while. You can reduce that risk by keeping the elements people already recognize, such as a color or part of the symbol, and by announcing the change. Talk this risk through openly with your designer when you decide how far the refresh should go.

If your company is refreshing its identity or building one from scratch, and you would like to talk through how to set up the proposal process, you can reach me through the logo and brand identity page. I will read your brief and send you a written proposal covering the scope, the process and the full deliverables list.

Tags

brand identity agencycorporate identity design servicescorporate logo design companybrand identity design proposalbranding agency rfp

Contact

Let's talk about your logo and identity

Write a few sentences about your business and how you want it to look, and I will reply with a written quote that includes the scope and timeline.

A few sentences are enough. I'll get back to you as soon as I can.

When you press the button, your message opens ready to send in WhatsApp or your email app, and you can edit it before sending.