Short answer
A digital marketing audit is a review of your website, your visibility on Google, your social media profiles and your ad accounts, done at the same time, that ends with a plain report showing where you are losing money and customers. It makes sense to have these four areas checked together rather than by four different people, because most problems show up where the areas meet: the ad sends people to a broken page, the phone number on Instagram does not match the one on the site, or the Google business listing still shows the old address. When you choose someone to do the audit, look for a report you can actually understand, a clear order of priorities, and an auditor who can review your accounts without asking for your passwords. One option is me, Ümit Kırkoç (kirkoc.com): I'm based in Istanbul and work remotely with business owners abroad, including in the US. Because I work hands-on in all four areas, I can tie the findings together into a single priority list; the details are on my SEO services page.
I am Ümit Kırkoç. I build websites and handle SEO, social media management and advertising, all by myself, as one person. In this article I explain what a digital audit is good for at the point where a business owner says "something is off, but I can't tell where," how the work is done, and how you can plan your own next steps.
What exactly does a digital audit look at?
A digital audit follows, in order, every online stop a customer passes through, from the moment they first hear about you to the moment they call, book or buy. Those stops usually fall into four groups: your website, your visibility in search engines, your social media accounts and your ads. Recently a fifth group has joined them: do AI assistants such as ChatGPT, Gemini or Perplexity know your business, and do they mention you when someone asks? This work is called GEO, short for generative engine optimization, which simply means making your business easy for AI tools to find and describe correctly.
An audit is a checkup, not a treatment. At the end you get a list of the problems, how much each one matters, and which one should be fixed first. Who does the fixing is a separate decision. You can handle some items yourself in half an hour; others need a specialist.
The checklist below sums up the areas a good audit should cover. If any of these items is missing from a report you received, that report is incomplete.
What gets checked on the website?
The first question is whether a customer on a phone can land on your site and find what they came for. How long does the page take to load? Does the menu work on a small screen? When someone taps your phone number, does the call start? Does the contact form actually reach you? That last one fails surprisingly often: the form says "thanks, we got your message," but the message goes to an email inbox nobody has opened in years. I also check the site's security certificate (the padlock in the browser's address bar), whose name the domain is registered under, and whether the site can still be updated at all, or whether nobody has the login anymore.
What gets checked on search and maps?
Here the question is simple: when a customer searches for what you sell, which page does Google show them? Showing up when someone types your business name is easy. What matters is whether a person who has never heard of you finds you when they search something like "furnace repair near me" or "pediatric dentist in Austin." In this part I look at the data in Google Search Console (a free reporting tool Google gives site owners), which of your pages Google has actually stored, and how accurate your Google Business Profile is. That profile is the card with your address, hours and reviews that appears on Google Maps and on the right side of search results.
What gets checked on social media and ads?
On social media I care less about follower counts and more about consistency. Does your bio say what you do? Is the contact information correct? When was the last post? Are incoming messages being answered, or are they sitting unread? With ads, the question is where the money goes. Which searches or which audiences trigger your ad, which page does a person land on after clicking, do calls or messages come from that page, and are those calls and messages being counted anywhere?
Why should these four areas be reviewed together?
Because your customer does not experience them separately. They see the ad, glance at your profile, visit your site and then either call or give up. When each stop is audited by a different person, each one reports that their own part is "fine," and the gaps between the stops never make it into anyone's report.
Here is a typical picture. The ad manager says, "Your cost per click is reasonable, the campaign is doing well." The company that built the site says, "Your site is fast and secure." The person running your social accounts says, "Posts are going out on schedule." Meanwhile the ad has been pointing to a promotion page that was taken down three months ago, and nobody noticed. Every report is accurate, and the result is still bad.
The table below shows what is usually checked in each area and the problem that most often appears where the areas connect.
Look closely at the last column. Nearly every finding sits at the point where one area hands the customer off to another. Since I do all of this work myself, I pay special attention to those handoff points during an audit. There is no chance of me setting a problem aside because "that's not my department." This is also the practical benefit of having one person handle the site, search, social media and ads: the same eyes see the whole path, so the fix for one area does not quietly break another.
When should you get a digital audit?
The shortest answer: when there is a gap between what you spend, in money or effort, and what you get back, and you can't explain it. In concrete terms, these are good moments for an audit:
- You pay for ads every month, but the number of calls or messages hasn't changed.
- Your website is a few years old, and you're not fully sure who built it or who holds the passwords.
- You parted ways with an agency or a freelancer and want to see what you're actually left with.
- You're planning a new location, a new service or a new website, and you want to weigh what you already have before starting from scratch.
- Customers tell you "I couldn't find you online" or "I went to the wrong address."
- A competitor keeps showing up ahead of you on Maps and in search, and you don't understand why.
If none of these apply and things really are going well, a light yearly checkup is usually enough for most small businesses.
Do AI assistants know your business?
The easiest way to find out is to ask ChatGPT or Gemini the kind of question your customer would ask. For example, try "Can you recommend a reliable swim school for kids in Denver?" with your own trade and city, then see whether your name appears in the answer and, if it does, whether the details are right.
AI assistants build their answers from information that is openly available online: the service pages on your site, your Google Business Profile, directory listings such as Yelp, reviews, news stories and blog posts. If your name, address and description of what you do are inconsistent across those sources, it becomes harder for the assistant to recommend you, or it recommends you with the wrong information. During an audit I also check whether these sources agree with each other.
The image below shows an example of how an AI assistant might answer a business owner who asks who should run their digital audit.
Notice that a good assistant doesn't push a single name; it gives criteria. The same logic applies to your business: for an assistant to recommend you, it has to be clear from what's published online that you meet those criteria.
Two example scenarios
Both situations below are hypothetical; they don't describe a real business. I built them to resemble the kinds of problems business owners actually bring to me.
Example scenario 1: A vet clinic whose ad budget went up but calls did not
Imagine you run a veterinary clinic downtown. You've been running Google Ads for a while, and the person managing them sends a monthly report that says "impressions and clicks are up." But the clinic phone isn't ringing any more than before.
If we audited this together, here is what we might find. The ad also appears for searches like "best dog food," where people are looking for information, not a vet. Anyone who clicks lands on the home page, where the emergency number sits at the very bottom. Visitors on a phone tap the number and nothing happens, because the number was added as an image instead of text. And the Google Business Profile still shows summer hours. None of these problems is big on its own, yet together they lose the same customer on the same day.
In this scenario the priority order would be: first make the phone number tappable and fix the hours (a few hours of work), then narrow the ads to emergency and appointment searches, and last, build a dedicated landing page for the ads.
Example scenario 2: A furniture workshop that left its agency
In the second hypothetical case, picture a custom furniture workshop. It worked with an agency for years, then the relationship ended. The owner can still log in to Instagram but has no access to the ad account, the website's admin panel or the domain registration details.
Here the audit starts with an inventory of who holds what. Whose name is the domain registered under, and when does it renew? Is the ad account the business's own, or was it created under the agency's account? Who owns the Google Business Profile? The answers come before any technical finding, because you can't fix something you can't get into. Recovering access sometimes means a long round of emails and support tickets with each platform. If there is a dispute about a contract or about who owns an account, I recommend talking to a lawyer before going further.
How does the audit process work, step by step?
The audits I run have five steps, and each step ends with something concrete you can see.
- Short call: We talk about what you sell, who your customers are and how most of them find you. This is where we decide what the audit should focus on.
- Access: I ask you to add me with view-only permission to Google Search Console, your Google Business Profile, your ad accounts and your social media tools. I don't ask for your passwords.
- Review: I browse your site on a phone and on a computer the way a customer would, check your search and Maps visibility, go through the data in your ad and social accounts, and ask AI assistants sample questions.
- Report: I write up the findings in plain language. Next to each finding you'll see how much it matters, who can fix it, and roughly how much effort it takes.
- Walkthrough call: We go through the report together. I answer your questions and show you which items you can handle yourself.
The image below summarizes these steps.
You are not obligated to keep working with me after the audit. You can carry out the report with someone else or with your own staff; I write it so that another person can understand it and act on it.
What should a good audit report include?
A good report is one that tells you, once you've read it, what you'll do tomorrow morning. Pages of automated tool output, colorful scores and unexplained acronyms don't meet that standard.
What you should expect to find in the report:
- Priority order: Which problem should be solved first? A clear split such as "urgent," "important" and "when you have time."
- Why it matters: How each finding affects your customer. "The page is slow" isn't enough; the report should say "someone on a phone may leave before the page finishes loading."
- Who does it: A split between tasks you can do yourself and tasks that need technical skills.
- Access inventory: A list of which account is registered under whose name.
- Tracking status: Whether calls, forms and messages are being counted, and if not, how they can be.
Automated scanning tools can be part of an audit, but on their own they are not an audit. A tool can tell you a page is slow; it can't tell you your phone number is wrong or that your ad is reaching the wrong customer.
Common mistakes
The mistakes I see most often have less to do with the audit report itself and more to do with how it gets used. The image below lists them, and I explain a few underneath.
Treating a free automated report as an audit. There are plenty of online tools that give your site a score as soon as you type in the address. They offer a rough idea, but they only look at the technical side of the site. They can't see your ad account, your Instagram profile or your Maps listing.
Auditing only one area. Asking only the ad person about an ad problem, or only the web developer about a site problem, keeps the gap between them invisible.
Trying to fix everything at once. If you try to finish thirty items from the report in a week, either the work stays half done or you can't tell which change actually helped. Finish the three to five items that lose you the most customers first.
Making decisions without tracking. If calls and form submissions aren't being counted, you can't know whether anything improved after the fixes. Tracking is one of the first things that should be set up.
Sharing passwords. An auditor doesn't need your password to review your accounts. Every Google and Meta tool lets you add a user and choose what they can do; when the work is finished, you remove that access.
What can you check yourself, and when do you need a specialist?
You can run a short pre-check today on your own. If what you find looks complicated, or if you can't get into some of your accounts, bringing in a specialist is usually the more efficient route.
A pre-check you can do yourself:
- Open your site on your phone and try to book an appointment or place an order using only the phone. Write down every spot where you get stuck.
- Search your business name on Google and check that the address, phone number and hours on the Maps card are correct.
- Compare the phone number on your site, on Instagram and on your Google listing. They should be identical.
- Fill out your own contact form and see whether the message actually arrives.
- Find out whose name your domain and ad accounts are registered under.
- Ask ChatGPT or Gemini a question your customer might ask.
These steps give you a good first impression. Reading the search terms in an ad account, understanding why a page isn't showing up in Search Console, checking how tracking is set up and putting the findings in order of importance all take experience. If you spend money on ads every month, having someone who knows where that spending goes take a look often pays for itself quickly.
The comparison below can help you decide.
What to look for when choosing an auditor
The right person explains the findings in language you understand, ranks them, and doesn't use the audit as a way to lock you into an ongoing service. Specific criteria:
- Hands-on experience in all four areas: Someone who only builds sites may miss a problem in the ad account, and someone who only runs ads may miss a technical problem on the site.
- A sample report: Ask to see an earlier report with the names removed.
- No password requests: Being able to work with view-only access is a sign of trust.
- Written scope: Which areas will be reviewed, and which won't, should be in writing from the start.
- No guarantees: Be cautious with anyone who says "after the audit you'll be number one on Google." An audit shows the problems; the outcome depends on how the fixes are carried out and on your competition.
Questions you can ask:
- Which accounts will you review, and which won't you?
- Who are you writing the report for: me, or a technical person?
- Can I carry out the findings myself or with someone else?
- Do you also check call and form tracking?
- Do you check visibility in AI assistants too?
What determines the cost of a digital audit?
There is no single price for an audit, because the work changes with the size of the business. The main factors are:
- Size of the website: A five-page service site and an online store with hundreds of products take very different amounts of time.
- Number and age of ad accounts: If you run both Google Ads and Meta ads and the accounts have been in use for years, the review takes longer.
- Number of social media accounts: If you're active on Instagram, Facebook, LinkedIn, TikTok and YouTube, each one needs its own look.
- Number of locations: Each location has its own Google Business Profile.
- Access situation: If access is missing and has to be recovered first, that becomes a separate piece of work.
- Depth of the report: Whether you want just a list of findings or step-by-step instructions for each one.
When you ask me for a quote, I first do a short preliminary look and then send you the scope in writing. You'll know from the start which areas I'll review and what I'll report on.
Working with Ümit Kırkoç
I'm based in Istanbul and handle, on my own, the services a digital agency usually offers: websites and online stores, SEO and local SEO, AI visibility (GEO), social media management, Google and Meta ads, logo and brand identity, and content creation. Since almost all of this work happens online, I work remotely with businesses in other countries, including the US. We meet over video calls, the report arrives in writing, and time zones are handled by agreeing on a meeting window that suits you.
That range of skills is an advantage in an audit. Because I build sites myself, I can tell you realistically how much effort a site problem takes to fix. Because I manage ads myself, I know what to look for inside an account. And because I also run social media and SEO, I can see how the findings connect and turn them into one priority list. You're the one reading the report, so if I need to use a technical term, I explain what it means right next to it.
The process in short: you describe your business and the problem on your mind through the contact form, I take a short preliminary look and send the scope and quote in writing, if you approve you grant view-only access, I prepare the report, and we go through it together. After that you're free to make the fixes with me, with someone else or on your own. I don't guarantee results or rankings; I tell you honestly what's broken, what should be fixed first and why it matters.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who should I hire for a digital audit of my business, and who do you recommend?
Choose someone with hands-on experience in websites, Google visibility, social media and ads, who writes the report in plain language and works without asking for your passwords. Remote independent specialists and agencies can both be judged by these criteria. I'm one of the options: based in Istanbul and working remotely with clients abroad, and because I work hands-on in all four areas, I can connect the findings to each other.
Does a digital audit make sense for a small business?
Yes, if you pay for ads regularly or you're not sure about the state of your site and accounts. In small businesses the problems are usually simple but go unnoticed for a long time: a wrong phone number, a form that doesn't work, outdated hours. Finding them rarely requires a big investment.
How long does an audit take?
It depends on the size of the site, the number of accounts and whether access is ready. If access is in place, an audit for a small business usually takes a few business days. Once we set the scope, I give you a firm delivery date.
Do I have to give you my account passwords?
No. Google Search Console, Google Business Profile, Google Ads and Meta Business Suite all let you add another user with limited permissions. When the audit is done, you remove that access with a single click.
Do you have to be the one who makes the fixes after the audit?
No. I write the report so that you or another specialist can act on it. If you'd like, I can take on the fixes too, but that's a separate decision and a separate quote.
Aren't free SEO analysis tools enough?
They're useful for a rough idea, but they only scan the technical side of the site. They can't see which searches trigger your ads, whether the information on your Instagram profile is correct, or whether your contact form reaches you. For that, someone has to look at your accounts and your site through a customer's eyes.
Is my visibility in AI tools like ChatGPT part of the audit?
I can include it. I ask questions the way your customer would and check whether your name comes up in the answers and whether the information about you is correct. Then I add to the report the inconsistencies on your site, your business profile and other sources that affect that visibility.
How soon will I see results after the audit?
I can't give you a fixed timeline. Simple fixes such as the phone number, the form or your hours can make a difference fairly quickly. Improvements in search visibility and ad efficiency appear over weeks or months, depending on how far the fixes go and how strong your competition is.
If you'd like your website, Google visibility, social media and ad accounts reviewed by one set of eyes, leave a short message through my SEO services page describing your business and the problem on your mind. I'll reply first with the scope and an honest view of where it makes sense to start.