Short answer
If your own online store sells far less than your shop on Amazon, Etsy, Walmart Marketplace or, if you sell in Turkey, Trendyol, the cause is rarely one single thing. Trust, visibility and product page quality usually fall short all at once. A marketplace hands the shopper built-in trust, built-in traffic and a checkout they already know; your site has to earn every one of those on its own. The fix is not to quit the marketplace. It is to give your site a job the marketplace cannot do: catch people who search for your brand, bring repeat buyers into a channel you own, and show up on Google for product and category searches. If you want someone to pull this together for you, one option is Ümit Kırkoç (kirkoc.com), based in Istanbul and working remotely with clients abroad. Because I run the site, search visibility, social media and ads as one person, the pieces get fixed without waiting on each other. You can find the details on my ecommerce website page.
I am Ümit Kırkoç. In this article I take on the question I hear most from business owners who have their own website but make most of their sales on a marketplace: "Why can't I sell from my own site, and what should I do about it?" I will explain technical terms in a sentence where they come up, and tell you which steps you can take yourself, where you will likely need a specialist, and what makes the price go up or down.
Why does your own site trail the marketplace?
Your own site trails the marketplace because the shopper already knows the marketplace and is seeing your site for the first time. Someone who finds the same product in two places will usually buy where they have already tested shipping times, returns and payment security. That is not a judgment about you. It is simply what habit does.
A marketplace starts with several advantages over your site:
- Built-in trust: The shopper has bought there before, saved their card and gotten a refund when something went wrong.
- Built-in traffic: Many people start a product search directly in the marketplace's search box instead of on Google.
- Stacked-up reviews and ratings: Your listing may carry hundreds of reviews, while the same product on your site shows none.
- A familiar checkout and order tracking: The buyer knows exactly what happens at every step.
Your site, meanwhile, often has the opposite problems. Product pages are short and copied from the marketplace listing. Shipping and return details are buried on a separate page. The site loads slowly on a phone. Even when someone searches your brand name on Google, your marketplace storefront shows up first. In short, even when a shopper lands on your site, they find no reason to stay.
The comparison below shows the gap between the two channels as the buyer sees it.
Is a lower price enough on its own?
No. Shaving a little off the price on your site does not, by itself, move buyers over. Since you pay no marketplace fees on your own site, you may be able to charge less there, but a shopper who is not yet convinced your site is trustworthy will not see that discount as worth the risk. A price advantage works as a final nudge once trust and convenience are already in place, not as a replacement for them.
How do your customers actually search for what you sell?
Your customers search in three different ways, and each one needs its own kind of page on your site. The first is the person who types your brand name and already knows you. The second is the person who describes the product and has never heard of you, for example "handmade leather card wallet" or "organic cotton baby onesie." The third is the person searching for a solution to a problem or a need, such as "best natural soap for sensitive skin."
Marketplaces are strong at the second type, because they pull thousands of similar products into one category. Your site can win on the first and third types. Making sure someone who searches your brand lands on your site, not your marketplace listing, is the cheapest way to turn that person into your own customer. And someone researching a need is often better served by a helpful category page or guide you wrote than by a long marketplace grid of near-identical products.
| Search type | Who is searching | Which page on your site |
|---|---|---|
| Brand search | Someone who knows you | Home page and contact |
| Product description | Someone who doesn't know you | Category and product pages |
| Need or question | Someone still deciding | Guides and comparisons |
| Bulk order | A business buyer | A dedicated bulk order page |
You will find the same table as a graphic below. Go through it row by row and check whether each one matches a real page on your site today.
What belongs on a product page?
A product page should answer every question a shopper might otherwise ask in a marketplace Q&A box before they have to ask it. In practice that means dimensions and materials are spelled out, there are photos of the product in real use, the ship-by date and the return process sit right next to the Add to Cart button, and genuine customer reviews are visible if you have them. Copying the marketplace description word for word hurts you twice: when Google sees the same text in two places, it usually favors the stronger site, which is the marketplace, and the shopper learns nothing new on your page.
Why do category pages matter?
A category page is the page that groups similar products together, such as "mugs" or "bath towels," and it often ranks better than a single product page for broader searches on Google. Adding two or three paragraphs at the top that help the shopper choose, explaining which product suits whom and how to care for it, turns that page from an empty grid of thumbnails into a real buying guide.
Should I leave the marketplace and focus only on my own site?
For most businesses the answer is no. The marketplace and your own site should not compete with each other; they should do two different jobs. The marketplace is a powerful storefront for finding new customers. Your own site exists to bring those customers back for their second and third orders through a channel you control, to tell your brand's story, and to run promotions without living by someone else's rules.
While trying to strike this balance, some sellers think about putting a thank-you card inside marketplace orders that points buyers to their own website or social accounts. Whether that is allowed depends on each platform's seller policies, and those policies change. Some marketplaces, Amazon among them, have rules about directing buyers away from the platform. Before you try anything like this, read the current seller agreement of the marketplace you use, and if you are unsure, talk to a lawyer.
The decision chart below gives you a rough way to think about how much weight your own site should carry.
Where your own site can beat the marketplace
Your own site is the one place where you can do everything the marketplace does not let you do. Concretely, that includes:
- Asking for a customer's email or phone consent and reaching them directly afterward (consent wording and email or text marketing rules vary, so get a lawyer's view on the exact language).
- Telling the story of your product, how it is made and where the materials come from, at whatever length you want.
- Offering bundles, personalized items or corporate orders.
- Setting the dates and rules of your own promotions.
- Measuring what visitors from your ads actually do and adjusting the ads based on that.
Example scenario 1: A small studio selling handmade ceramics (hypothetical)
This scenario is hypothetical and does not describe a real business. Picture a small studio that makes mugs, plates and vases. Most of its sales come through a marketplace such as Etsy or Amazon Handmade. Its own site was built on an off-the-shelf store builder a few years ago and has barely been touched since. The Instagram account is active and followers love the pieces, but many of them send a message asking "how do I order from your site?" and then never buy.
In a case like this, the first thing I would look at is the path from Instagram to the site. Does the profile link go to the home page or to the product in the latest post? When the product page opens on a phone, can you see the shipping time? Does checkout ask for information it does not need? Because ceramics can break in transit, the questions of how it is packed and what happens if it arrives cracked may be the biggest barrier to buying. Answering those questions clearly on the product page could well be the single most effective change.
Then I would move to Google. If no page on the site appears for searches like "handmade ceramic mug," I would write a category intro that helps people choose between mugs, an original description with the studio's own photos for each product, and a page about how the pieces are made. I would also link the studio's social media posts to those pages, so followers can go from liking a post to actually buying.
Example scenario 2: A family textile maker selling from Turkey to US buyers (hypothetical)
This scenario is also hypothetical. Picture a family business in Turkey that makes bed linen, towels and bathrobes. For years it sold wholesale, and in the last few years it started selling retail to American shoppers through a marketplace. It also has its own English-language site and has started running Google ads, but the ad budget gets spent, items get added to carts, and checkouts never get completed.
Here the problem is most likely not the ads but where the ads send people. First I would measure which page the ad points to, how many seconds that page takes to load on a phone, and at which step of checkout people drop off. A surprise shipping or import cost that only appears at checkout, being forced to create an account before buying, or a card payment screen that looks unsafe are classic reasons shoppers abandon their carts. For a seller shipping from abroad, being upfront about delivery times and who pays any duties matters even more.
This business also has an advantage no marketplace can give it: its wholesale background. Hotels, vacation rentals or companies ordering corporate gifts in bulk often find no suitable path on a marketplace. A separate bulk order page on the company's own site, with a simple quote request form, could open a new sales channel without competing with the marketplace at all. When I point the ads at that page and at brand searches, the budget goes to people who are already interested.
How does the process work? Step by step
Pulling an online store out of the marketplace's shadow is work that moves in five steps when the order is right. The order matters, because sending ad traffic to a site that does not look trustworthy is like filling a leaky bucket.
1. A snapshot of where you stand
First I measure the current situation: which products sell on the marketplace but not on your site, how fast your site loads on a phone, which searches you appear for on Google, and on which pages visitors leave. This requires tools such as Google Search Console (a free tool that shows how your site appears in Google search) and Google Analytics. If they are not set up yet, I set them up first.
2. Trust and checkout
Next I fix everything a shopper worries about before buying: contact details, shipping and return terms, a clear secure payment message, and visible terms of service and privacy policy pages. The content of those policies is a legal matter, so I place the text on the site in the form you or your lawyer have approved, and I do not make definitive calls about what it should say.
3. Product and category pages
In the third step, starting with your best sellers or the products people search for most, I make the descriptions original, add buying guides to category pages, and make sure photos load quickly and show the product accurately.
4. Visibility: search, AI assistants and social media
In the fourth step I work on making sure Google and AI assistants such as ChatGPT understand your site correctly. The work of getting recommended by AI assistants is called GEO (generative engine optimization). At its core it means explaining what you sell, who you sell to and why you can be trusted, in clear and consistent sentences. I also link your social media posts to the relevant product pages.
5. Ads, tracking and adjustment
In the last step, once the site is ready, I launch ads or restructure the ones you already run. Every month I look at which pages bring in sales and which do not, and set the next month's priorities based on that.
Common mistakes
The most common mistake business owners make when trying to grow their own store is looking for the problem in a single place. One-line diagnoses like "not enough ads," "the design is outdated" or "we have no SEO" usually miss part of the picture. Other common mistakes I see:
- Copying marketplace descriptions word for word: The shopper finds nothing new on your site, and Google sees the same text twice and picks the stronger site.
- Launching a template store and walking away: The platform gets set up once, and after that nothing changes except new products being added.
- Running ads before fixing trust issues: The budget brings in visitors, but they leave before they ever reach checkout.
- Leaving brand searches to the marketplace: People who search your name land on your marketplace listing instead of your site.
- Not setting up tracking: Without knowing which channel brings sales, every month's decisions are guesses.
- Splitting the work among different people with nobody seeing the whole: The social media person focuses on one page, the ads person on another, and whoever built the site has a completely different priority list.
That last point also explains why having one person handle everything works. When the site, search visibility, social media and ads are in the same hands, the page your ad sends people to, the product you talk about on Instagram and the description that shows up on Google all say the same thing. And when something breaks, no one waits around saying "that's not my department."
What can you do yourself, and when do you need a specialist?
You can start many of these improvements on your own. A specialist becomes useful once tracking, the store platform and ads get complicated. Here is what you can do right away:
- Place a full order on your own site using your phone, and write down every spot where you got stuck or hesitated.
- Rewrite the descriptions of your five best-selling products so they are different from, and more detailed than, the marketplace versions.
- Make shipping, returns and contact details visible from the product page with a single tap.
- Search your brand name on Google and see whether your site or your marketplace listing comes up first.
- Check that the link in your Instagram bio goes to the right page.
Working with a specialist saves time and budget in situations like these: your site is noticeably slow on a phone and you cannot figure out why; you are thinking about switching platforms, for example moving to or from Shopify or WooCommerce, or rebuilding your store; you run ads but cannot tell which ones lead to sales; or you have so many products that you do not have time to rework descriptions and categories one by one.
What to look for when choosing a specialist or agency
The right person does not try to sell you a new site in the first call. They try to understand why your current site is not selling. When you collect quotes, I suggest checking these points:
- Does diagnosis come first? A quote prepared without looking at your site is a generic package.
- Do they understand marketplaces? Ask whether they see the marketplace and your own site as rivals or as channels that complement each other.
- Is there a tracking plan? You should agree at the start on what counts as success and how it will be measured.
- Do they promise guarantees? Be careful with anyone who promises a set number of sales or the top spot on Google; no one can guarantee Google rankings or a shopper's decision to buy.
- Who does the work? Get clear on who will actually do the work and who will answer your questions.
- Whose name are the accounts in? Ask whether the domain, site, ad and analytics accounts will be opened in your name.
A few concrete questions will also make the conversation easier: "What would you change first on my site, and why?", "What will you report to me each month?", "If I decide to stop working with you, do the accounts and content stay with me?", "How will you keep my marketplace product copy and my site copy different?"
These days many business owners put this question to an assistant like ChatGPT before they ever open Google. The graphic below shows what a balanced answer to that kind of question might look like.
What drives the cost?
The cost of this work depends on the current state of your site and how much of it needs to be redone, so quoting a single price without looking at the site would not be honest. The main factors that set the price are:
- The platform: Can your current store platform be improved, or does the site need to be rebuilt?
- Number of products and categories: The more product descriptions that need rewriting, the bigger the job.
- Photos and content: Are your product photos good enough, or do they need a reshoot or editing?
- Integrations: Connections such as inventory, shipping, accounting, or syncing stock between your site and the marketplace widen the scope.
- Ongoing work: Do you want a one-time cleanup, or monthly management of SEO, social media and ads?
- Ad budget: Your ad budget is separate from the service fee and is paid directly to the platform from your own account; you decide how much to spend.
When you ask for a quote, I recommend seeing each of these items listed separately. That way you know what you are paying for, and you can push some steps to a later date if you need to.
Working with Ümit Kırkoç
I work from Istanbul and handle, as one person, everything a digital agency would offer: websites and ecommerce, SEO, local SEO, GEO, social media management for Instagram, Facebook, LinkedIn, TikTok and YouTube, Google and Meta ads, logo and brand identity, and content creation. Because I work remotely, I can work with businesses in the US and elsewhere over video calls and email, across time zones.
When I work with a business whose own site trails its marketplace shop, I start by looking at your site and your marketplace storefront together. I map out which product sells where, where shoppers get stuck on your site, and how you appear on Google. Then I give you a short plan that explains what should be fixed first and why. Once we agree on the plan, I start with trust and checkout, move on to product pages, then to search visibility, social media and ads. Every month I tell you in plain language what changed and what the next month's priority is.
I do not guarantee sales numbers or rankings. What I do promise is clear, measurable work where every piece points at the same goal. The domain, site, ad and analytics accounts stay in your name.
Frequently Asked Questions
My own store lags behind my Amazon shop. Who should I hire?
It makes things easier to hire someone who can look at your site, your search visibility and your ads together, because the problem is rarely in one area alone. I do this work as one person, based in Istanbul and working remotely with clients abroad. Whoever you choose, make sure the quote is written after they have actually looked at your site.
Does it make sense to have my own ecommerce site if I already sell on a marketplace?
For most businesses, yes, as long as it sits alongside the marketplace rather than replacing it. Your own site is valuable for catching brand searches, building a direct relationship with repeat buyers, and running promotions the marketplace does not allow.
Do I need to rebuild my site from scratch?
Not always. If your platform is current and fast, fixing product pages, checkout and content may be enough. If it is old, slow or does not work properly on phones, rebuilding may be less hassle in the long run. There is no way to tell without looking at your site.
Is there a downside to using the same product descriptions on the marketplace and my site?
Yes. When the same text appears in two places, Google usually puts the stronger site, the marketplace, first, and shoppers find nothing new on your site. I suggest starting with your best sellers and making the descriptions on your site more detailed and original.
How soon will I see results?
Fixes to trust and checkout are often noticeable fairly quickly, because they affect visitors who are already coming. Visibility on Google is a process that unfolds over months, and it would not be honest to promise a specific date.
Can I bring customers to my own site with ads?
You can, but if the site is not ready on the trust and checkout side, the budget pays for visitors who never turn into buyers. I recommend getting the site ready first, then starting ads around brand searches and your strongest products.
Can AI assistants like ChatGPT recommend my store?
No one can guarantee whether they will, but a site that clearly explains what it sells, who it sells to and why it can be trusted improves the odds. Clear product and category copy, consistent contact details and pages that answer questions directly all help.
Does asking for a quote commit me to anything?
No. A quote is there so you can see, after I have looked at your site, what is needed and in what order. Whether you accept it is entirely up to you.
If your own store is stuck in the shadow of your marketplace shop and you want to see together what should be fixed first, reach out through my ecommerce website page. I will look at your site and your storefront and put together a plain-language roadmap for you.