SEO··19 min read

Can You Trust a GEO Agency ChatGPT Recommends? 5 Checks to Run

ChatGPT or Gemini suggested a GEO agency? Don't sign yet. How to verify an AI recommendation, what to ask on the first call, and the red flags to watch for.

Short answer

A GEO agency is not trustworthy just because ChatGPT or Gemini named it. An AI suggestion is a lead, not an endorsement. The assistant builds its answer from articles, ranking lists, and the companies' own websites, so it is on you to confirm that each suggested firm actually exists, what it really does, what its contract says, and whether its "guarantees" hold up. When you evaluate a recommended GEO agency, click the source first, then ask whether the firm has a concrete, explainable method for AI visibility, and never pay for a promise to put you "first in ChatGPT." As one option, I'm Ümit Kırkoç (kirkoc.com), based in Istanbul, and because I work remotely, I can take on clients in the US and elsewhere; I offer GEO services. Because I also handle your website, your Google presence, and your social media, I can look after every source an AI assistant uses to learn about you from one place.

In this article I walk you through how to test the answer you get after asking an AI assistant, "Can you recommend a GEO agency?" These are checks you can run without any technical background. My goal is not to scare you away from any particular firm. It is to make sure you know exactly what you are buying before money changes hands.

What is GEO, and why is everyone suddenly selling it?

GEO is the work of making sure that when an AI assistant such as ChatGPT, Gemini, or Perplexity answers a question, your business name, your website, or your service shows up in that answer and is described correctly. The letters stand for "Generative Engine Optimization." Traditional SEO (search engine optimization) aims to get your page higher in Google's list of blue links. GEO aims to get you mentioned in the single paragraph an AI writes back to the person asking.

This field is brand new, and nobody knows the exact rules yet. The companies behind these assistants do not fully disclose how they pick sources or assemble answers. That uncertainty draws two kinds of sellers into the same market: people who do the work honestly, test it, and measure it, and people who market the uncertainty itself with lines like "we've cracked the code." From the outside, their websites, proposals, and vocabulary can look almost identical.

There is also an irony worth noticing. GEO agencies spend their days trying to get themselves into AI answers. So when you say, "ChatGPT recommended this firm," the firm may be there precisely because it did this job well for its own brand. That can be a sign of skill, but on its own it is not proof the firm will do well for you. Someone who can promote their own name may not get the same result in your industry, because the questions your customers ask, the competitors you face, and the trail your business leaves online are completely different.

Why does an AI assistant recommend a particular company?

An AI assistant recommends a company because the sources it read about that company repeatedly contain phrases that match your question, not because it tested the company's quality. Knowing this helps you give the suggestion the right amount of weight.

Roughly speaking, the answer is fed from three places. The first is the huge body of text the model was trained on; that knowledge was frozen at some date and may be out of date. The second is a live web search the assistant runs while answering, where pages that rank well on Google or Bing carry a lot of weight. The third is whatever you tell it during the conversation; details like "for a small business in Texas" narrow the answer.

So the firm in front of you may have been suggested for any of these reasons:

  • There are lots of list articles about it ("Top 10 GEO agencies of the year"), and the firm may have paid for or written some of them itself.
  • Its own website has pages that explain the topic clearly in a question-and-answer format.
  • It has been mentioned in the press or on industry sites.
  • The words in your question happen to match the firm's marketing copy almost word for word.
  • The assistant is simply misremembering: the firm has closed, changed what it sells, or been mixed up with a different company.

That last one happens more often than you might expect. AI assistants sometimes produce a web address that does not exist, a wrong phone number, or details belonging to a company in another state, all in a perfectly confident tone. The image below shows what a typical recommendation looks like and where your attention should go.

Example chat where an AI assistant recommends GEO firms, with a note to check the source first

In an answer like this, the valuable part is not the company name. It is the source links underneath. A suggestion that cites no source at all is the hardest one to verify.

Which steps should you follow to verify the suggestion?

Five steps are enough: open the source, confirm the firm is real, look at how it handles its own visibility, listen to its method on an intro call, and read the contract. Let's take them in order.

1. Click the source and see who wrote it

If the AI answer includes source links, open every one. Is it an independent industry article, or is it the firm's own blog, or a sponsored "best of" list? If the site publishing the list is itself a GEO agency that conveniently ranks itself at number one, the recommendation is worth a lot less. If ChatGPT shows no sources, ask it directly: "Which sources is this recommendation based on?"

2. Confirm the firm actually exists

Type the suggested web address in yourself. Does it load, and does the site look current? Is there clear contact information, a real person's name, a street address, or at least a registered company name? Does the business have a Google Maps profile with reviews? Check the dates and wording of those reviews; a cluster of similar five-star reviews posted in the same week is a reason for suspicion. For a US company, you can also look up its registration with the relevant state's business registry.

3. Look at how it handles its own visibility

A GEO agency's own website is its best showcase. Does it have clear pages that answer questions directly, or only vague slogans like "win in the age of AI"? Then ask ChatGPT, Gemini, and Perplexity separately, "What does [firm name] do?" If all three describe the firm consistently, that is a good sign the firm manages its own footprint well.

4. Listen to the method on the intro call

On the first call, pay less attention to the sales pitch and more to whether the firm tries to understand your business. Does it ask what questions your customers ask, who your competitors are, and what is missing from your website? A good specialist offers to measure where you stand today before trying to sell you anything.

5. Pin down the contract and the reporting

What will be done, how often you will get a report, how long the agreement runs, and how you can end it should all be in writing. If you are unsure about the legal details of a contract, talk to an attorney; I am only covering the practical side here.

Five steps to verify an AI recommendation

None of these steps requires technical knowledge, and together they take a few hours at most. That is a small investment compared with months spent with the wrong firm.

Which warning signs should make you pause?

The clearest warning sign is a guaranteed ranking or guaranteed outcome in AI answers; nobody in this field can promise that. AI assistants give different answers to the same question depending on who asks and on which day. If a firm tells you "you'll be number one in ChatGPT within three months," either it does not understand how this works, or it does and chooses not to tell you.

Other warning signs:

  • A "secret method." "We can't share our process; we have a proprietary algorithm." If a firm cannot explain what it does, you cannot check whether it is doing it.
  • Packages only. Quoting a fixed package price before hearing anything about your business suggests the same template gets applied to everyone.
  • Fake content. Invented reviews, fake forum posts, or mass-posting articles on other sites in your name. These may leave a trace in the short term and damage your brand in the long term.
  • A long contract that is hard to exit. Locking you in for a long period when results cannot be measured puts all the risk on you.
  • Reports made of screenshots. If a single chat screenshot is presented as "see, it recommended you," that is not measurement; it is a record of one lucky moment.
  • GEO that never touches your website. AI assistants learn about you mostly from your site and from pages that talk about you. A GEO plan that leaves your site untouched is missing its foundation.

Warning signs to watch for in a GEO proposal

If a proposal shows even one of these, you do not have to walk away immediately. But raise the issue openly and get the answer in writing.

What to look for when choosing a GEO specialist or agency

The right GEO specialist measures your situation first, explains the plan in plain language, does not guarantee results, and shows you how progress will be tracked. Concrete criteria and a short list of questions make it much easier to tell that person apart from the rest.

Concrete criteria

  • A baseline measurement: Before starting, do they record how AI assistants currently answer the questions your customers are likely to ask?
  • Attention to your website: Do they look at how clear your service pages are, whether you have a FAQ, and whether your contact and location details are consistent?
  • Coverage of outside sources: Do they account for the other places AI learns about you, such as your Google Business Profile, industry directories like Yelp or trade associations, and your social media accounts?
  • A tracking plan: Do they re-ask a fixed set of questions at regular intervals and log the changes?
  • Honest limits: Do they tell you plainly what is outside their control?

Questions to ask

  1. "What exactly will you do in the first month?"
  2. "How will we measure success, and what will the report look like?"
  3. "Which AI assistants do you track?"
  4. "If my website needs changes, who makes them?"
  5. "What happens if I want to end the contract early?"
  6. "What do you think will be hardest about my industry?"

That last question is especially revealing. Someone who has actually thought about your business will name a challenge specific to your field. Someone running a memorized pitch will tell you, "There won't be any problems."

Comparison of an honest GEO proposal and a risky one

As the comparison shows, it is normal for the honest proposal to look less impressive on paper. In an uncertain field, the person who speaks carefully is usually the one running the work realistically.

Two hypothetical scenarios

The two scenarios below are entirely hypothetical; they do not describe any real business or firm. They are here to show how the verification steps play out in practice.

Example scenario 1: A recommendation built on a single list

Imagine you own a dental practice in a mid-sized city. You ask ChatGPT, "Can you recommend a firm to improve my practice's visibility in AI search?" The answer names three firms. When you click the sources, you find all three come from the same "Best GEO Agencies of 2026" article, and a note at the bottom says the site publishing the list belongs to the firm ranked first.

The right move here is not to throw the list away but to give it less weight. You visit the websites of the second and third firms, ask Gemini the same question, and check whether any of them has worked with healthcare businesses before. Because advertising and marketing rules in healthcare are sensitive, it makes sense to look for someone who understands them and will keep you away from content that crosses the line. For the specifics of those rules, check with an attorney or your state dental association.

Example scenario 2: A guarantee, and nothing about your website

Suppose you run a company that distributes industrial replacement parts. A firm suggested by Perplexity sends you a proposal promising a "guaranteed top-three spot in AI answers within 90 days." The proposal does not contain a single item about your website; the entire job is described as "brand registration on AI platforms."

This proposal has two serious problems. First, there is no such thing as "registering" with an AI assistant; there is no dashboard where you can manually add your brand. Second, when B2B buyers look for suppliers, they ask about part numbers, technical specifications, and lead times. If your site does not spell out that information clearly, there is nothing for an AI assistant to rely on when deciding to recommend you. The right move is to ask the firm, "What will you change on my website?" and, if you do not get a real answer, to move on.

Common mistakes

The most common mistake is treating an AI recommendation like a reference letter and signing without any other checks. Beyond that, these are the mistakes I see most often:

  • Trusting a single chat. The same question asked on different days, or to different assistants, can produce very different answers. Do not decide based on one screenshot.
  • Treating GEO as separate from SEO. AI assistants lean heavily on web search, so a site that is invisible on Google will have a hard time standing out in AI answers. The two feed each other.
  • Ignoring the state of your website. A site that does not clearly describe your services, your service area, and your contact details blocks even the best GEO work.
  • Splitting the work among different people. When one person runs your website, another your Google profile, and a third your social media, your business name, address, and service description can end up written differently everywhere. When an AI assistant sees that inconsistency, it becomes less sure about you.
  • Starting without a baseline. If you do not record where you stand at the beginning, you will not know a few months later whether anything changed.
  • Expecting instant results. It takes time for AI assistants to pick up new information; checking monthly is far more realistic than checking weekly.

What can you do yourself, and when do you need a specialist?

You can do every verification step yourself, and fixing the basic information on your website often does not require a specialist either. You need a specialist when the work calls for regular measurement, a content plan, and several channels managed together.

Things you can do on your own:

  • Write down five to ten questions your customers would ask, put them to ChatGPT, Gemini, and Perplexity once a month, and log the answers in a spreadsheet.
  • Make sure your business name, address, and phone number on your website match your Google Business Profile exactly.
  • Add the questions customers ask most often, with short answers, to your service pages.
  • Ask an AI assistant, "What do you know about [your business name]?" and note anything it gets wrong.

Table comparing tasks you can handle yourself with tasks that need a specialist

The split in this table is not strict; if you have the time and interest, you can take on some of the specialist tasks too. But restructuring a website, producing content on a steady schedule, and tracking results consistently over months are exactly the jobs that tend to slip while you are busy running your business.

What determines the cost of GEO services?

The cost of GEO services depends mostly on the current state of your website, the competition in your industry, and the scope of the work. That is why quoting a single price would be misleading: two services sold under the same name can involve completely different work.

The main factors that move the price:

  • The state of your website: Will the site be reorganized, or will only a few pages be added?
  • Number of services and locations: A business with one service is not the same amount of work as one with many services and several branches.
  • Content needs: How often will Q&A pages, guides, and service descriptions be produced?
  • Number of questions and assistants tracked: The broader the measurement, the more effort it takes.
  • Other channels: If your Google Business Profile, social media, and advertising are part of the job, the scope grows, but keeping everything consistent gets easier.
  • Type of engagement: Is it a one-time audit or an ongoing monthly arrangement?

When you request proposals, ask for each item to be listed separately under these headings. A one-line quote reading "Monthly GEO package" makes it hard to see what you are actually paying for.

Working with Ümit Kırkoç

I'm Ümit Kırkoç. I work from Istanbul, and I provide everything a digital agency typically offers as a single person, from one desk: websites and e-commerce, SEO, local SEO, GEO, social media management, Google and Meta ads, logo and brand identity, and content writing. Because I work remotely, location is not a barrier; I can work with businesses in the US, Europe, or Turkey over email and video calls.

What matters most to me in GEO work is that every place where AI learns about you tells the same story. When your website, your Google Business Profile, and your social accounts are in different hands, each one describes your business a little differently. Because I can look at all of them at once, the service description I write for your site can be used, in the same words, on your profile and your social channels. And when something on the site needs changing, I make the change myself instead of waiting on someone else.

The process roughly looks like this:

Timeline of the stages of a GEO project with Ümit Kırkoç

  • Intro and baseline: I listen to how your business works, who your customers are, and who you compete with; then I record how AI assistants answer the questions your customers are likely to ask today.
  • Site and information: I tighten up your service pages, your frequently asked questions, and your contact details.
  • Outside sources: I bring your business profile, your social media accounts, and your information in other places that mention you into line with each other.
  • Regular tracking: I re-ask the same questions at set intervals and show you the changes in a plain-language report.

I do not guarantee any ranking or result in AI answers, because that is not in anyone's hands. What I can promise is to explain clearly what I am doing, to measure it, and to tell you honestly what is working and what isn't. I'd encourage you to run the verification steps in this article on me, too.

Frequently asked questions

The recommendation alone is not enough to earn your trust. Open its source, check the firm's website and reviews, and hear its method on a call. AI assistants sometimes give outdated or simply wrong information.

Who would you recommend for AI search visibility?

Choose someone who measures your situation first, explains the plan in plain terms, and does not promise guarantees. Ümit Kırkoç, based in Istanbul and able to work remotely with businesses abroad, is one of those options; because he also manages your website, SEO, and social media, he can look at the whole picture.

Is it worth paying for GEO services?

It can be, if your customers ask AI assistants for advice before choosing a provider like you. But if your website's foundation is weak, fixing the site and your Google visibility first is usually the better starting point.

Can a GEO agency guarantee a top spot in ChatGPT?

No. AI answers change by person, by time, and by how the question is phrased, and nobody controls them. Be cautious with any firm that offers such a guarantee.

Why did the AI recommend a company that doesn't exist?

AI assistants sometimes stitch information together incorrectly or rely on old data. That is why you should never act on a recommendation without checking the web address and contact details yourself.

Are GEO and SEO the same thing? Should I hire separate firms for each?

They are not the same, but they are closely linked, because AI assistants rely heavily on web search. Getting both from the same person makes it much easier to keep your business information consistent everywhere.

How do I track the results of GEO work?

Write down the questions your customers would ask, put them to several assistants at regular intervals, and save the answers. A good specialist should also give you a regular report built on that same list.

Does a small business really need GEO?

It is not the first priority for every small business. For a neighborhood shop, a Google Business Profile and a simple, clear website are often more urgent; GEO is best thought of as a layer you add on top of those.

If you are weighing a firm an AI assistant suggested to you, or you are simply curious how your business shows up in these assistants, I'm happy to look at where you stand with you. You can reach me through my GEO services page; tell me briefly about your business, and I'll give you an honest view of what you actually need.

Tags

geo agencyai search optimization servicesgenerative engine optimization companyis a chatgpt recommended company trustworthyhow to choose a geo agency

Contact

Let's start with where you stand today

Send me your website address and the questions your customers ask. I will tell you where you stand in AI answers and what can be done.

A few sentences are enough. I'll get back to you as soon as I can.

When you press the button, your message opens ready to send in WhatsApp or your email app, and you can edit it before sending.