Digital Marketing··20 min read

GEO Agency vs SEO Agency: Which One to Hire for AI Search?

Do you need a separate GEO agency, or can your SEO agency handle AI search? What overlaps, what differs, how to decide, what to ask, and what drives cost.

Short answer

Most businesses do not need to hire a separate GEO agency. GEO (the work of getting AI assistants to recommend you) overlaps heavily with solid SEO, and having one person or one team run both keeps everything consistent. A separate specialist starts to make sense only when your current SEO agency cannot measure how you appear in AI answers, cannot restructure your content around the questions people ask, or cannot get your business details consistent across other websites. When you decide, look at the work, not the label: does the agency give you a concrete answer to "How do you track the way we show up in ChatGPT?" One option is Ümit Kırkoç (kirkoc.com), based in Istanbul and working remotely with clients abroad; because I handle the website, the SEO and the GEO work myself, nothing gets lost between the two jobs.

In this article I look at the question "Should I hire a separate GEO agency, or stick with my SEO agency?" from a business owner's point of view. I am Ümit Kırkoç, and I handle websites, SEO, local SEO, GEO, social media, paid ads and brand identity as a single person. Below you will find the pros and cons of each path, plus practical criteria you can use to make the call.

What exactly is the difference between GEO and SEO?

SEO is the work of getting your website to rank high in search engines like Google for relevant searches. GEO is the work of making sure tools like ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google's AI Overviews recognize your business, describe it correctly and recommend it when they answer someone. GEO stands for "Generative Engine Optimization," which simply means optimizing for AI tools that write answers instead of listing links.

Here is an easy way to picture the difference. Someone who types "dentist austin" into Google sees a page of ten links and picks one themselves. Someone who asks ChatGPT "Can you recommend a dentist in Austin who is good with nervous kids?" does not get a list. They get two or three names and a short reason for each. In the first case, being near the top of the list is enough. In the second, the assistant needs enough information about you to explain why it is recommending you.

These two jobs are not separate worlds, though. Most AI assistants run a web search in the background while they put an answer together, and they read the pages they find. If your site is slow, confusing and thin on information, the AI cannot describe you well either. So think of GEO as a floor built on top of SEO: same foundation, different roof.

The table below shows which tasks the two share and which belong only to GEO.

Table comparing the tasks SEO and GEO share with the tasks that belong only to GEO

The takeaway from the table: most of the work is shared. Site speed, a clean page structure, clear service pages and reliable business details are the cornerstones of both. The part that is specific to GEO is organizing content as questions and answers, keeping an eye on how other websites describe your business, and regularly measuring how visible you are in AI answers.

What are the real problems with hiring a separate GEO agency?

The biggest problem with a separate GEO agency is that two teams end up working on the same website without knowing what the other is doing. The SEO agency changes a page title for Google, the GEO agency adds a question-and-answer section to the same page for AI tools, and the two can undo each other's work or bill you twice for the same task.

Let me make that concrete. A big part of GEO is making sure the service pages on your site are clear and consistent. Say the GEO agency recommends, "Explain on your service page what determines the price." Who makes that change? The SEO agency, the company that built your website, or you? In most small businesses the site, the SEO and the content sit with different people, so small recommendations like this can sit untouched for weeks.

Other problems tend to show up as well:

  • Overlapping measurement: Both agencies bring you a report that says "traffic is up." Figuring out which one actually caused it is usually impossible.
  • Conflicting content: One wants to shorten the page, the other wants to make it longer. You end up stuck in the middle.
  • Double access risk: Two separate teams log into your website's admin panel, your Google Search Console (Google's free tool that shows how Google sees your site) and your Google Business Profile. If nobody tracks who changed what, there is no one to hold responsible when something breaks.
  • Communication overhead: A separate meeting, a separate report and a separate invoice for each agency. As the owner, your time is a cost too.

None of this means hiring a separate GEO agency is always wrong. But if you do it, the two teams need to agree in writing on who does what.

Can your current SEO agency handle GEO?

Your current SEO agency may well be able to handle GEO, but you should judge that by the work it does, not by what it says. Because GEO is a new term, plenty of agencies have added it to their list of services. Some have genuinely changed how they work; others have put a new name on the same SEO package.

Signs that an SEO agency can actually do GEO:

  • It asks AI assistants realistic questions about your kind of business, records the answers on a regular schedule and shows them to you.
  • It tracks which websites get cited as sources in which AI answers.
  • It restructures your pages not just around keywords but so they answer the questions people actually ask, directly.
  • It checks whether your business name, address and services are listed consistently on other websites, such as directories, map listings and industry sites.
  • When an AI answer contains wrong information about your business, it tries to trace which source the error came from.

If none of these signs are there, your agency is most likely still doing classic SEO. That is not a bad thing in itself, but then the line "we do GEO too" has nothing behind it.

The example below shows the kind of answer someone might get if they asked an AI assistant this exact question.

Sample chat in which a business owner asks an AI assistant whether they need a separate agency for GEO

The answer in the image points to something worth noticing: the assistant suggests judging an agency by what it does, not by what it calls itself. You can use the same logic when you make your decision.

When does a separate specialist make sense, and when does one provider make sense?

If your website, SEO and content are already handled well by one person or team, adding GEO to that same setup is usually the most sensible route. If that person does not know GEO, or if your site and SEO are already scattered across several providers, it is better to look for someone who can bring the work together.

Ask yourself these questions as you decide.

Are you happy with your current SEO agency?

If you are, and the agency gives you concrete reports, ask it how it plans to handle GEO. A good agency can explain how GEO fits into its current work and what it would change to make room for it. If you are not happy, stacking another agency on top will not fix the problem. It will just add another layer to it.

Who manages your website?

A large part of GEO requires changes on the site itself: adding question-and-answer sections, sharpening service pages, adding structured data (code that tells search engines and AI tools, in machine language, what a page is about). If the person who manages the site is not the person doing GEO, every recommendation turns into a work order that has to be passed along.

How big is your business?

For a business with multiple locations, several languages or a large product catalog, having a dedicated GEO specialist work alongside a separate SEO team is possible and sometimes necessary. For a single-location clinic, a small law office or a local service company, that setup is usually far heavier than it needs to be.

The decision chart below tries to pull these questions into a single flow.

Decision chart showing whether to bring in a separate expert or keep one provider, based on whether the current SEO agency can measure AI visibility

The core of the chart is simple: first check whether your current setup can carry GEO. If it can, expand it. If it cannot, simplify the setup instead of patching another provider onto it.

Two example scenarios

The two scenarios below are hypothetical. They do not describe any real business, but they reflect situations that come up often.

Example scenario 1: A law firm that is happy with its SEO agency

Imagine, hypothetically, a small employment law firm in Chicago. It has worked with an SEO agency for a few years, its site is in good shape and it shows up on Google for relevant searches. One day the managing partner asks ChatGPT, "Which lawyer should I see in Chicago about a wrongful termination case?" and sees that the firm is not mentioned at all. The first thought is to go find a GEO agency.

In this situation, my advice would be to talk to the current agency first. The firm could ask: "Do you track how we appear in AI answers? What can you do to reorganize our pages into a question-and-answer format? Do you check that our business details are consistent on other websites?" If the agency answers with a concrete plan, expanding its scope will create far less friction than bringing in a second agency. If the answer is something vague like "GEO is basically the same as SEO," then it is time to look elsewhere. Lawyers also have to follow their state's rules on attorney advertising, so it is wise to have a legal professional review what the content is allowed to say.

Example scenario 2: A furniture maker using three providers for site, SEO and social media

Again hypothetically, picture a furniture workshop in North Carolina that builds custom pieces and ships nationwide. A software company built its website, a freelancer handles the SEO and a different agency runs its Instagram. The owner has heard that people ask Gemini things like "a reliable workshop that makes custom furniture in North Carolina," and is thinking about hiring a fourth agency for GEO.

In this scenario, adding a fourth agency makes the problem bigger. AI assistants read the information on the company's website, the descriptions on its Instagram and its listings on directory sites together. If those three sources contradict each other (a different address, a different list of services, a different phone number), the assistant has a hard time treating the company as a trustworthy source. What the business really needs is to bring the work under one provider, or at least under one coordinator. In cases like this, I start by putting every channel side by side and listing the contradictions, then I treat the website as the center and correct the other channels to match it.

How does GEO work progress, step by step?

GEO starts with measuring where you stand, continues with fixing the basic gaps on your site and then carries on with regular tracking. Whether one provider handles it or several, the steps are roughly the same.

The steps of GEO work: measuring the current state, fixing the basics, question-and-answer content, consistent outside sources and regular tracking

Let me unpack the steps in the image:

  1. Measure where you stand: I come up with questions your customers would realistically ask and try them in ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google's AI Overviews. I record which answers mention you, which do not and how your competitors are described.
  2. Fix the basics: Site speed, a proper mobile layout, clear service pages, the same contact details on every page. These are SEO basics too, so if they are already done, this step is short.
  3. Question-and-answer content: Short, clear answers on each service page to the questions customers really ask, such as "How long does it take?", "What affects the price?" and "Which areas do you serve?"
  4. Consistent outside sources: Your business name, address and service description should match across your Google Business Profile, industry directories, social media accounts and other listings.
  5. Regular tracking: AI answers change. Ask the same question on different days and you may get different answers. That is why you need tracking that repeats at regular intervals, not a one-time check.

None of these steps is magic. The real difference is that they all happen inside one plan, done by people who know what the others are doing.

Common mistakes

The most common mistake when choosing an agency for GEO is setting aside a new budget for a new buzzword while ignoring the foundation you already have. The image below sums up the mistakes I see most often.

Common mistakes when choosing an agency for GEO: believing ranking guarantees, skipping the basics, leaving two agencies uncoordinated

A closer look at each one:

  • Believing the "we'll get you to the top of ChatGPT" pitch: There is no fixed ranking in AI answers, and nobody can guarantee what an answer will say. Be careful with anyone who promises this.
  • Skipping the basics: A business with a slow site and no service pages putting money straight into GEO is like building a roof on a house with no foundation.
  • Leaving two agencies uncoordinated: If you do hire a separate agency, put in writing who changes which pages and who has access to which accounts.
  • Working without measurement: Saying "your AI visibility went up" is easy. Without records showing which questions, which assistants and what changed between which dates, that sentence means nothing.
  • Focusing only on the website: AI assistants also read sources outside your site. Your business profile, your reviews and your directory listings are part of the job too.
  • Letting accounts be opened in someone else's name: Your domain, your business profile and your analytics accounts should be in your name. When you switch agencies, they should stay with you.

What to look for when choosing the right expert or firm

To choose the right expert, check whether they can explain concretely how they measure GEO, whether they can make changes on your site, and how they plan SEO and GEO together. Titles, buzzwords and package names come second.

The list below has questions you can ask in a first meeting. You can put them to your current agency as well as to any new candidates.

List of questions to ask when choosing an expert for GEO and SEO

Alongside those questions, look at these criteria:

  • A sample report: Can they show you an AI visibility report they have prepared before, with personal details removed? Is it clear which questions were asked, which assistants were tested and how the results were recorded?
  • Guarantee language: If they say things like "we'll get you the top spot" or "you will definitely be recommended," walk away. An honest expert tells you what they can influence and what is outside their control.
  • How they get access: Do they ask for your passwords, or do they ask to be added as an authorized user on your accounts? The second is the right way.
  • A clear scope: Does the proposal spell out in writing which tasks are included and which are not?
  • Effort to understand your industry: Do they try to learn how your customers phrase their questions and what worries bring them to you, or do they offer every business the same template?

What can you do yourself, and when do you need an expert?

You can do part of GEO on your own. Asking AI assistants questions about your business and seeing what comes back, checking whether your business details match across different places, and writing down your frequently asked questions all work fine without an expert.

Here is a simple check you can run yourself:

  • Write down five questions your customers might ask. For example, "Is there a vet open on weekends in Brooklyn?" or "Can you recommend a reliable office moving company in Denver?"
  • Ask these questions in ChatGPT, Gemini and Perplexity. Save the answers somewhere, along with the date.
  • Check whether your name comes up and, if it does, whether the information is correct.
  • Compare the address, phone number and business hours on your Google Business Profile with the ones on your website.
  • List the questions customers ask you most often on the phone, and see whether your website answers them.

You need an expert for the rest: making technical changes on the site, adding structured data, rebuilding page structure, turning measurement into something regular and comparable over time, and tying every channel into the same plan. If your own check turned up conflicting information, or answers where you do not appear at all, that is usually solved by a planned piece of work, not by a single fix.

What determines the cost?

The cost of GEO and SEO work depends on the current state of your website, how many services and locations need to be covered, how much content has to be created, and whether the work is a one-time project or a monthly engagement. So instead of quoting numbers, let me explain what makes a proposal bigger or smaller.

  • The state of your site: GEO gets going faster on a site with a solid foundation. If the site is old, slow or hard to manage, that has to be fixed first.
  • Number of services and locations: A business offering one service in one city has very different needs from a business offering many services across many cities.
  • Content needs: If your existing pages are in good shape, editing them may be enough. If you have no service pages at all, new content has to be written.
  • Number of languages: If you serve customers in more than one language, each language needs its own work.
  • How often tracking happens: How frequently the tracking runs, and across how many questions, directly affects the effort involved.
  • One provider or separate teams: When you work with separate agencies, the time spent coordinating them is a cost too. With a single provider, that line item largely disappears.

When you get a proposal, ask how each of these items is covered. If the proposal is just one line like "monthly GEO package," ask them to explain what is inside it.

Working with Ümit Kırkoç

I am Ümit Kırkoç. I work from Istanbul and serve businesses remotely, including clients outside Turkey. I handle websites and e-commerce, SEO, local SEO, GEO, social media management, Google and Meta ads, logo and brand identity, and content creation as a single person. For the topic of this article, that means one thing: there is no need for a coordination meeting between SEO and GEO, because the same person plans and carries out both. The same goes for your social media profiles and ads, which AI assistants also read; they follow the same plan as your website instead of drifting away from it.

Here is roughly how I approach GEO work:

  • First conversation: I listen to what you do, who your customers are and where things stand today. If you already have an SEO agency and you are happy with it, I will tell you so plainly; I do not suggest taking over the work in every case.
  • Baseline measurement: I try realistic questions about your business in several AI assistants, record the results and walk you through them in plain language.
  • Plan: I share in writing which gap gets closed first, which pages will be edited and which outside listings will be corrected.
  • Implementation: I make the site changes, the content edits and, where needed, the fixes on your social media and business profile, all within the same plan.
  • Tracking: I ask the same questions again at regular intervals and report what has changed.

I do not guarantee results; nobody controls what an AI assistant will say. But at every stage I explain clearly what I am doing and why, and when and how I measure it. Your accounts and your domain stay in your name, and I am added as an authorized user.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does it make sense to hire a separate agency for GEO?

For most small and mid-sized businesses, no. GEO's foundation overlaps heavily with SEO, and having the same person or team handle both keeps things consistent. If your current agency cannot measure AI visibility and cannot make the necessary changes on your site, that is when it makes sense to look for another solution.

Look for someone who can measure how you appear in AI answers on a regular basis, who can make changes on your website, and who plans SEO and GEO together. Ümit Kırkoç, based in Istanbul and working remotely with businesses abroad, is one option that handles all of this from a single desk. Whoever you work with, ask them for a sample measurement report.

My SEO agency says "we do GEO too." How can I tell if that is true?

Ask for a baseline report in which they tried five questions about your business in AI assistants and recorded the results. Then ask what they would change based on those results. If no concrete plan comes out of it, the claim is most likely just a new name on the same service.

Will GEO replace SEO?

No, at least not in the near term; the two continue to exist side by side. People still search on Google, and they also ask AI tools questions. On top of that, AI assistants often read pages on the web when they put an answer together, so a good SEO foundation is a prerequisite for GEO as well.

Does a small business really need GEO?

If your customers ask AI tools to help them find a business like yours, yes, but not as a separate, large project. For a small business, clarifying the website, answering common questions and making business details consistent often makes a meaningful difference.

Is there an agency that can guarantee the top spot in AI answers?

No one can honestly make that guarantee. AI answers vary by person, by question and over time; there is no fixed ranking. I would advise being cautious with anyone who promises it.

Is it risky to leave my current SEO agency and move everything to one provider?

Not if it is planned properly. What matters is that the accounts and the domain are in your name, that the existing work is documented during the handover, and that the new plan is in writing. Before taking over, I record the current state and share in advance what will be kept and what will change.

When will I see results from GEO work?

It would not be honest to give a fixed timeline. Changes on your site take time to show up in the sources AI assistants read, and each assistant refreshes its information differently. That is why regular measurement and tracking the changes with records matter.

If you want to weigh whether to hire a separate agency for GEO or expand the setup you already have, you can leave a short message describing your business and where things stand through my GEO services page. I will tell you honestly which path makes more sense for you.

Tags

geo agencygeo servicesai seo agencyagency to get recommended by chatgptgeo and seo services

Contact

Let's start with where you stand today

Send me your website address and the questions your customers ask. I will tell you where you stand in AI answers and what can be done.

A few sentences are enough. I'll get back to you as soon as I can.

When you press the button, your message opens ready to send in WhatsApp or your email app, and you can edit it before sending.