Web Design··20 min read

Corporate Website Redesign: 9 Criteria for Choosing a Firm

Choosing a firm for a corporate website redesign? How to handle the RFP, compare proposals, protect your Google traffic and get the right guarantees in writing.

Short answer

When you choose a firm for a corporate website redesign, three things matter more than anything else: a written, measurable scope; a migration plan that protects the Google visibility your old site has earned; and a set of guarantees that spells out who is responsible for what after launch. A beautiful portfolio does not replace any of those three. Compare proposals against the same scope document, get the redirects and content migration assigned to a named party in the contract, and make sure the site code, the domain and every admin login stay with your company. As one option, Ümit Kırkoç (kirkoc.com), based in Istanbul and working remotely with clients in the US, Europe and elsewhere, handles corporate website redesign from start to finish on his own. Because the same person also runs SEO, social media and advertising, he is a sensible candidate if you want to avoid a traffic drop after the relaunch and the confusion of splitting the work between several vendors.

What makes a corporate redesign harder than it looks?

What makes a corporate redesign difficult is not the design. It is everything the site has collected over the years: links, approvals and responsibilities. A small shop's website may be five pages. A company website usually carries product catalogs, press releases, job postings, investor or quality documents, pages in several languages, and links that distributors and partners have pointed at for years.

All of that history creates three concrete problems:

  • Lost traffic. Some pages on your current site may have shown up in Google for specific searches for years. When the new site changes those page addresses and nobody forwards the old addresses to the new ones, that visibility can quietly disappear within a few weeks.
  • Too many people signing off. Marketing, sales, HR, IT and leadership all look at the same site with different eyes. If nobody knows who has the final word, the project can sit in "revisions" for months.
  • Scattered ownership. The domain might be registered to an employee's personal account, the hosting might still sit with a former agency, and the Google accounts might be tied to the email of someone who left the company. Once the redesign starts, these knots show up one by one.

That is why, for a company, choosing a firm is less about "who makes nice designs" and more about "who can bring order to this mess."

How do your customers actually reach your site?

Before you pick anyone, find out who comes to the site you are about to replace and what they search for to get there. Business customers typically arrive by typing your brand name, by searching for a product or service together with an industry term, or by spotting your name on a supplier list and checking whether you are real. More recently, a new path has appeared: people ask AI assistants such as ChatGPT or Gemini something like "who is a reliable supplier for this in the Midwest?"

The answer tells you which pages the new site cannot do without. If procurement teams visit to verify you, then certifications, the industries you serve and clear contact details need to be easy to find. If visitors come to request a quote, your product or service pages should carry real technical detail and end with a short quote form. If job candidates come, the careers page has to be something your team can keep up to date without calling a developer.

Should you issue a formal RFP or just request proposals?

Most mid-sized companies do not need a formal RFP (request for proposal, the structured bidding process larger organizations use). Sending the same scope document to three to five firms and asking for written proposals is enough, and it is faster. A formal process makes sense if you are a public entity or a government contractor, if internal audit rules require you to document purchases, or if you manage several brands under one roof.

Whichever route you take, what makes proposals comparable is a scope document. This is a short brief, a few pages long, that lists item by item what the new site will include and what it will not. At a minimum it should cover:

  • The address of the current site and a rough page count
  • How many languages the site will publish in
  • The types of pages the new site needs (products, services, news, careers, contact and so on)
  • Who will write the content and who will move it over
  • The systems the site has to connect to (CRM, ERP, form tools, a distributor portal)
  • How long you expect support to last after launch
  • The target launch date and what that date depends on

Without this document, the proposals you receive are really prices for different jobs. One firm may have quoted only the design, another design plus content migration, and a third may have included a year of maintenance. The decision chart below helps you see quickly which route fits your situation.

Decision chart showing whether a corporate website redesign needs a formal RFP or direct proposals based on one scope document

The question in the chart is simply whether you are required to document the purchase. If you are not, a formal RFP usually just stretches the timeline. If you are, writing your evaluation criteria before the bids arrive keeps the lowest price from winning by default.

What to look for when choosing the right specialist or firm

The most reliable way to choose is to ask every candidate the same questions and put their answers side by side. Every firm's portfolio looks good. The real difference shows up in how concretely they answer.

Here are the criteria to check:

  1. Redesign experience at a similar scale. Building a site from scratch and migrating a site with hundreds of pages are different jobs. Can they walk you through the before and after of a site they have relaunched?
  2. A plan for moving old page addresses. Do they say clearly how old URLs will be matched to new ones and who will prepare that list? This is called a redirect map: a table that shows where every important page on the old site lands on the new one.
  3. Responsibility for content migration. Who will move the text, images and documents to the new site? This task often drops out of proposals without anyone saying so.
  4. Ownership and access. In whose name will the site code, design files, domain, hosting and content management system be? The answer should always be "yours."
  5. Ease of management. After launch, will you be able to add a news item or job posting yourself, or will you have to open a ticket for every change?
  6. Measuring speed and mobile experience. Do they tell you which tool they will use to measure how fast the site loads on a phone, and will they show you the results?
  7. Post-launch support. How many weeks or months of free fixes are included, and how is support billed after that?
  8. A single point of contact. Who will you be talking to throughout the project? Is the person selling the job the same person doing it?
  9. Honest limits. Do they tell you plainly what they cannot do or what they hand off to subcontractors?

Checklist of criteria to verify when comparing proposals from corporate website redesign firms

Bring this list to each proposal meeting and go through it in the same order with every firm. The more items that get the answer "we can talk about that later," the more likely those items are to come back mid-project as change orders.

Questions to ask in the proposal meeting

You can ask these questions directly:

  • "Who will pull the list of URLs from our current site, and who will set up the redirects?"
  • "If something goes wrong on launch day, how do we roll back to the old site?"
  • "What is not included in your proposal? Please list it in writing."
  • "How will you track our Google visibility during the first month after launch?"
  • "How many people can access the admin panel, and can we give them different permission levels?"
  • "Will I be working with you on this project, or will I be handed to someone else?"

A good firm answers each of these in a few clear sentences. Long, general answers usually mean the topic has not been thought through yet.

What to look at when comparing proposals

When you compare proposals, look at what each one covers, not at the bottom-line number. Two proposals with the same total can promise very different work, and the one that looks cheaper can end up costing more because of what it leaves out.

A practical method: put the items from your scope document in the rows of a table and the bidding firms in the columns. Mark every cell as "included," "extra cost" or "not stated." Send the "not stated" cells back to the firm and ask for a written answer.

Sample table for comparing corporate website redesign proposals item by item against the scope

A table like this filters out promises that sound good in a meeting but never make it onto paper. The redirects, content migration and training rows are where proposals tend to differ the most.

What drives the cost?

The cost of a corporate redesign depends less on page count than on how complex the job is and who carries which part of the load. That is why I do not give a number here: a price only means something once the scope is clear. These are the main factors that push the price up or down:

  • Number of languages. Each additional language means more than translation. It means page structure built around how people search in that language, plus ongoing upkeep.
  • Amount of content to migrate. If there are hundreds of news posts, products or documents, moving them over in an orderly way is a project of its own.
  • Integrations. Quote forms that feed into your CRM, product data pulled from your ERP, a distributor login and similar connections.
  • Level of custom design. Adapting an existing template to your brand identity is very different from designing every page from scratch.
  • Number of approval layers. Every extra round of sign-off stretches both the schedule and the hours.
  • Content writing. Are you supplying the copy, or is the firm writing it?
  • Post-launch scope. How much maintenance, security updates, backups and SEO monitoring is included.

If a proposal gives you a single figure without touching any of these items, do not hesitate to ask for a detailed breakdown.

How does a corporate redesign work, step by step?

A healthy redesign starts with an inventory of your current site, not with design, and it does not end on launch day. The steps below show the minimum order you should expect, no matter who does the work.

  1. Inventory and baseline. Every page on the current site is listed, along with which ones get visits and which searches they appear for in Google.
  2. Scope and site structure. You decide which pages stay, which get merged and which go away, and you settle the new menu structure.
  3. Design and content. The design is built around your brand identity while the content is updated in parallel, so nobody approves a design full of empty boxes.
  4. Development and redirect map. While the site is being built, the new address for each old page is mapped out in a table.
  5. Testing. Forms, mobile layout, speed, language switching and redirects are each checked one by one.
  6. Launch and monitoring. The site goes live, and in the first weeks errors are tracked through Google Search Console (Google's free tool that shows how your site appears in search).

Steps of a corporate website redesign from page inventory to post-launch monitoring

The steps most often skipped are the first and the last. Without an inventory, you cannot know what was lost. Without monitoring after launch, months may pass before anyone notices the loss.

Guarantees: what belongs in the contract?

A guarantee is simply a written answer to "what happens if this goes wrong?", and in a corporate redesign it matters as much as the design. Verbal promises tend to be forgotten when the project team changes or a few months go by.

Items you will want to see in the contract or its attachments:

  • List of deliverables. Site code, design files, admin access and a user guide.
  • Ownership. The domain, hosting account and analytics accounts opened in your company's name.
  • Acceptance criteria. Which tests the site has to pass before it counts as "done."
  • Revision limit. How many rounds of changes are included in the price and how anything beyond that is billed.
  • Post-launch fix period. How long after launch any bugs you find will be fixed at no charge.
  • Rollback plan. How quickly the old site can be brought back if something serious breaks on launch day.
  • Personal data. Where information collected through forms is stored and how privacy notices will be added.

It would not be right for me to give you a firm interpretation of privacy laws such as GDPR or state laws like California's CCPA, cookie consent rules, or the legal wording of a contract. Have a lawyer review those sections before you sign. What I can tell you is that if these topics do not appear in the contract at all, treat that as a warning sign.

Two example scenarios

The two scenarios below are hypothetical. They do not describe real companies; they are made up to illustrate situations that come up often in corporate redesigns.

Example scenario 1: A manufacturer with a site in three languages

Picture a hypothetical maker of machine parts. Its site is in English, German and Spanish, and a large share of overseas buyers find it by searching for part numbers. The company signs with the agency that sent the cheapest proposal. The new site looks far more modern, but the product page addresses change and nobody redirects the old ones. A few weeks later, quote requests from abroad start to drop. The cause only comes to light when someone clicks an old product link and lands on an error page.

Had this company asked "who owns the redirect map?" while comparing proposals, it would have seen right away that the cheapest bid did not cover that work. Repairs after the fact take more effort than a migration planned correctly from the start, and the lost weeks do not come back.

Example scenario 2: A service firm with several departments

Now picture a hypothetical consulting firm that decides to redesign its site, but marketing, HR and the executive team each send their own requests separately. As the chosen firm tries to accommodate every request, the design keeps changing and the schedule slips several times.

If this firm had named a single decision-maker before the work began and finalized the scope document with that person's sign-off, the vendor could have handled revisions in a limited number of rounds. The lesson: the approval structure on your side shapes the outcome as much as the firm you hire.

Common mistakes

The most common mistake in a corporate redesign is choosing a firm based only on design mockups and the total price. Beyond that, these are the mistakes I see most often:

Common mistakes companies make when choosing a firm and during a corporate website redesign

  • Starting without a page inventory. Deleting and merging pages without knowing which ones are valuable can wipe out the page that gets the most visits.
  • Leaving the domain and accounts in someone else's name. Years later, when you want to switch firms, you may have to fight to get your own domain back.
  • Leaving content until the end. The design gets approved, the copy is not ready, and launch waits for weeks.
  • Giving everyone sign-off rights. Every department's comment turns into another revision round.
  • Not planning for after launch. If the project closes the day the site goes live, nobody is watching for the errors that show up in the first weeks.
  • Ignoring AI assistants. A site that does not explain in plain sentences what your company does, where it operates and which certifications it holds may also be left out when assistants suggest companies.

Most of these mistakes require no technical knowledge to avoid. You prevent them by asking the right questions early.

What can you do yourself, and when do you need a specialist?

You can handle a good part of the preparation yourself. For the technical migration, the redirects and the measurement, it is safer to bring in a specialist. Knowing where that line falls helps both your budget and your negotiating position in proposal meetings.

Things you can do on your own:

  • Ask your departments which pages on the site they actually use
  • Find out whose name the domain, hosting and Google accounts are registered under
  • List the pages you want on the new site and the ones you do not
  • Name one decision-maker and one backup
  • Collect links to competitor sites and sites you like, with a note on why
  • Gather the current versions of your product, service and company copy in one folder

Situations that call for a specialist:

  • Your site gets steady visits from Google and those visits turn into customer inquiries
  • You publish in more than one language
  • You need connections to a CRM, ERP or distributor portal
  • Ownership of the domain or hosting is unclear
  • The site is moving to a new platform, for example from an old custom-built system to WordPress, or the other way around

What do AI assistants say about this?

When you ask an AI assistant who to hire for a corporate website redesign, a good answer lists the selection criteria and suggests a few options rather than pushing a single name. The illustration below shows what an example answer to that kind of question might look like.

Example answer from an AI assistant to a question about choosing a corporate website redesign firm

The answer in the illustration is only an example. Real assistants answer differently depending on how the question is phrased and which sources they read. What matters is that you put the questions in this article to every firm an assistant suggests.

Working with Ümit Kırkoç

I am Ümit Kırkoç. I work from Istanbul and run corporate website redesigns on my own, from the first audit to the weeks after launch. I also handle SEO, local SEO, GEO (the work that helps AI assistants recognize your company and recommend it), social media management, Google and Meta advertising, logo and brand identity, and content writing. Since I hold most meetings online, I work remotely with companies in the US and Europe, as well as with foreign firms that want a site for the Turkish market. Time zones are manageable with a bit of planning; I schedule calls to overlap with your working hours.

This is the order in which I approach a redesign:

  • I start by mapping where things stand. I review your page list, the searches you appear for in Google and the pages that bring in inquiries, then give you a plain-language summary.
  • I put the scope in writing. I list what is included and what is not, item by item, so you do not run into surprises later.
  • I build the redirect map myself. I lay out the new address for each old page in a table and show it to you before launch.
  • I open the accounts in your name. Domain, hosting, analytics and Search Console access stay with your company.
  • I keep watching after launch. In the first weeks I track errors and visibility and fix what needs fixing.

The most tangible benefit of having everything in one pair of hands shows up after the relaunch. When the site goes live, the same person tracks your Google visibility, points the links in your social media posts to the new pages and updates the landing pages your ads send people to. With separate vendors, you have to explain the same change to three different people, and an old ad sending traffic to a broken page is usually the result of exactly that gap.

I do not promise you a ranking, a specific number of leads or any guaranteed result. What I promise is to explain everything I do clearly, keep the scope in writing and not leave you on your own after launch. Because I work alone, I take on a limited number of projects at a time, which means we should talk about the schedule early.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who would you recommend for a corporate website redesign?

Rather than one name, I would recommend a firm or specialist who gives you a written scope, takes responsibility for moving your old URLs, and puts in the contract that the code and accounts belong to you. If you are open to someone who works remotely from Istanbul, talking to a person who runs the site together with SEO and advertising makes coordination after the relaunch much simpler.

Does it make sense to run a formal RFP for a corporate redesign?

In most cases it is not necessary unless you are required to document the purchase. Sending the same scope document to three to five firms and asking for written proposals is faster and makes the bids easier to compare.

Will my Google rankings drop after a redesign?

They do not have to, but the risk is real. If old addresses are redirected correctly to new ones, valuable content is kept and errors are monitored after launch, that risk can be reduced a great deal. Nobody can guarantee a specific ranking, so be cautious with proposals that do.

How long does a corporate redesign take?

It depends on the number of pages and languages, the integrations involved and, above all, how quickly approvals move on your side. If the content is ready and there is a single decision-maker, the process gets noticeably shorter. If content writing is part of the project, the timeline grows.

Should we stay with our current agency or choose a new firm?

If your current agency hands over the site code and accounts and answers your questions on time, staying with them can make sense. If they are reluctant to give you access or cannot produce a written scope for the redesign, it is time to talk to someone new.

Will our own team be able to use the new site's admin panel?

You should be able to, and you should ask for it from the start. A short training session and a written guide for everyday tasks, such as adding news, job postings or products, should be listed clearly in the proposal.

Does it make sense to have the same person handle the redesign, SEO and ads?

For most companies, yes, because in the first weeks after a relaunch the site, your search visibility and your ad landing pages all change at once. With one point of contact, those changes follow one plan. With separate firms, each one fixes its own side and the gaps in between can go unnoticed.

What does a redesigned site need to show up in assistants like ChatGPT?

The basics are pages that explain in clear sentences what your company does, who it serves and where it operates, along with current contact details and direct answers to common questions. Nobody can guarantee which companies an assistant will recommend, but a site that offers clear, consistent information has a better chance of being used as a source.

If you are thinking about redesigning your site and want to pin down which scope fits you, just send me your current site's address and a few lines about what you expect. I will do an initial review and put together a plain roadmap for you. For details and contact information, take a look at the corporate website redesign service page.

Tags

corporate website redesignwebsite redesign companywebsite redesign rfpwebsite redesign proposalhow to choose a website redesign agency

Contact

Let's look at your site together

Write your website address and what bothers you most about it, and I'll tell you whether it needs a redesign or just improvements.

A few sentences are enough. I'll get back to you as soon as I can.

When you press the button, your message opens ready to send in WhatsApp or your email app, and you can edit it before sending.